After more than six years of toggling between a state psychiatric hospital and the Flagler County jail, Joseph Bova II goes on trial Monday morning, Sept. 23, for the February 2013 murder of Zuheili Roman Rosado. The young mother of five was a nighttime store clerk at the Mobil mart on State Road 100, near the I-95 interchange, when Bova walked in and shot her execution style. He has confessed to the murder. His defense is not disputing that he murdered Rosado.
But the defense is claiming Bova, who has had competency issues, was insane at the time. If there hasn;t been a last-minute change, Monday morning the trial begins with jury selection expected to take all day. The trial itself may take most of the week. It will be tried before Circuit Judge Terence Perkins, the fourth judge to sit on the case. Bova is represented by Joshua Mosley, a public defender. He will be prosecuted by Assistant State Attorney Mark Johnson.
Perkins on Aug. 2 found Bova competent to proceed with trial, drafting a four-page order judging him so. Bova has been evaluated by two experts, including Dr. Dara Granger who, the judge wrote, found that Bova “was cooperative with her examination and readily disclosed pertinent facts of the cause and incident. He appeared to be able to accurately recall the pertinent facts of the incident and relate those facts in an orderly and comprehensive manner. She also opined that the defendant understood the necessity of appropriate courtroom behavior and could manifest appropriate behavior during all court proceedings.”
Both of those facts were significant: Bova over the years had seemed disconnected from the shooting of Rosado, and on several occasions in court, his behavior was unpredictable, at times aggressive: he threatened a judge’s life, and once claimed that the police had fabricated the case against him. Earlier this month he refused to show up at his last hearing before trial. In recent weeks, the concerns have been with his hygiene. He has not bathed regularly. But courtroom bailiffs were prepared for all possibilities regarding Bova. It is possible that he may not show up for every day of the trial.
The defense is arguing insanity: Bova, his attorney wrote the court, “expects to prove that he is suffering from a neuropsychiatric disorder with symptoms of psychosis and neurocognitive deficits at the time of the offense alleged in the Indictment and at the current time. Defendant expects to prove Defendant lacked the ability to understand the nature and consequences of his actions at the time of the alleged offense, that Defendant was in a state of psychosis at the time of the alleged offense, and that Defendant was insane at the time the First Degree Murder alleged in the Indictment was committed.”
Three witnesses will be called in an attempt to prove his insanity: Ann and Henry Bova of Wolcutt, Connecticut, where Bova grew up, and Albert Esposito of Flagler Beach.
Bova has spoken in court about his own insanity, but to speak of his assumptions that if he is found to have been insane, he would be released. The judge has attempted to explain to him that that would not likely be the case, as he would more likely be held in a psychiatric hospital.
The judge may still have to rule on one or more pre-trial motions before the proceedings. Depending on Perkins’s schedule with Monday morning arraignments, jury selection would begin at some point Monday morning in Courtroom 401 at the Flagler County courthouse. Below, for background, is the previous story published about the case, along with numerous links filling in the details over the last six years.
Despite Concerns and Strange Behavior, Joseph Bova Once Again Judged Competent To Be Tried in Rosado Murder
July 26, 2019—This time, it was Joseph Bova himself who made the strongest case for his competency and to proceed to trial: “I’m definitely competent, sir,” Bova told the judge. “I’ve been competent for several months. I’ve been to those [state psychiatric] hospitals, there’s no need for me to go back to those hospitals, it’s a big waste of time.”
It was as if Bova himself has tired of the way this case has dragged for so long.
Six years after he was charged with the first-degree murder of Zuheily Roman Rosado at the Mobil convenience store on State Road 100 in Palm Coast, Bova was yet again back in court this morning for a hearing to determine his competency to stand trial. And yet again he was found competent to proceed despite his attorneys’ attempt to convince the court that he does not understand the gravity of his case.
Bova was found competent to proceed in previous years only to “decompensate,” or regress, psychologically, to the point where he had to be sent back to a state psychiatric hospital and judged incompetent to stand trial. This time, Circuit Judge Terence Perkins, the fourth judge to hear the case, appears as determined as Bova to hold a trial.
Despite his concerns, Perkins ruled to that effect after a three-hour hearing that featured the testimonies of three experts, two of whom considered Bova competent, one of whom did not, and of Bova himself, who on two occasions during the hearing sought to fire Josh Mosley, his lead attorney and public defender. The reason: Mosley was seeking to have Bova found incompetent.
But the judge said he would reverse himself if Bova were to not cooperate with his attorneys and doctors seeking to evaluate him from here on.
A trial date will be set in early September, possibly for Sept. 16, though defense attorneys are asking for more time. “Time is not our friend,” Perkins said. “Let’s proceed with all due speed.”
Bova’s courtroom antics, conscious or not, are not unusual. He has previously threatened a judge’s life, claimed he was the victim of a conspiracy by law enforcement, and sought to represent himself. Today’s behavior was only mildly unusual in comparison.
Bova looked disheveled, his hair and beard overgrown and scraggly. He had apparently not bathed in many days: his attorneys spoke of his “odor.” He was not brushing his teeth. His eyes were puffed out, making his face look so distorted, as it had the last time he was in court, that the judge asked him: “What’s wrong with your eyes?”
“Allergies,” Bova said. One of the doctors who testified–Joseph Sesta, who considers him incompetent–said he could not explain the distorted face and had not seen it in his experience.
Bova wants to plead not guilty by reason of insanity. He thought he could work out a plea with prosecutors. The judge told him that may not be in the cards (it isn’t). “Then I’d plead NGI and take the trial,” Bova said, using the acronym for “not guilty by reason of insanity.”
Sesta during his testimony revealed to the court that Bova had been involved in a severe crash: he was riding a bike when he was 13 and struck by a vehicle going at 50 miles per hour. Sesta said Bova was unconscious for at least 10 minutes at the scene of the crash before paramedics arrived. Though Bova walked out of the hospital the next day with what was found to have been a concussion, Sesta said the crash may have triggered a predisposition to schizophrenia and other mental issues. His psychiatric hospitalizations began when he was 14 and 15, continuing after that. There’s no question about his diagnosis as a schizophrenic.
The question this morning revolved around his ability to understand that he’s charged with first degree murder, that he understands the divide between defense and prosecution, the adversarial nature of the proceedings and the potential heavy penalty–up to life in prison–he faces if found guilty.
Sesta didn’t think Bova understood all that. “He seems oblivious to the adversarial nature of the legal process,” he said, referring to how Bova in court even today tried to strike a plea with the prosecution, apparently thinking he could walk out a free man if he was found insane at the time of the murder.
That day in February 2013, Bova walked into the Mobil Mart convenience store, walked to the counter, and shot Rosado several times, execution style. He then walked out. The shooting was captured on surveillance video. Bova had covered his face. But he had been in the store earlier, uncovered, and wearing the same clothes. His motive for the shooting has never been known.
He was last found competent to stand trial in February by the state psychiatric hospital where he’d been held most of the past six years. Perkins was ready to set a trial date. But Bova’s attorneys in May, after Bova had been transferred to the Flagler County jail, argued that he had “decompensated” and was no longer fit for trial. That led to today’s hearing, repeating the see-saw maneuvers that have had Bova in and out of court, in and out of the psychiatric hospital, for the past six years.
“I continue to believe that Mr Bova is not competent to proceed on the current charges,” Sesta said.
Darah Granger, a clinical psychologist, and Roger Davis, a forensic psychologist, disagreed. Granger testified by phone and Davis in person that Bova was following directions, was largely aware and appreciative of the case and its ramifications, behaves in court, and could stand trial. “I didn’t see any evidence that he was feigning incompetence,” Davis told the court. Bova had been suspected of feigning incompetence in the past–before his own insistence that he is now ready to proceed.
Mosley in his argument to the court described a Bova oblivious to his surroundings, apathetic in his cell, taking his medicines but at irregular hours, refusing to step out, to meet with doctors or to eat his meals, and decompensating to the point of being incompetent.
Mark Johnson, the prosecutor, described Bova as he was in court today–answering questions and understanding what was asked of him–and relied on the experts’ testimonies to conclude that Bova was “in fact competent.”
It was up to the defense to meet the burden of proof to show that Bova was incompetent. “I find that he is competent to proceed,” Perkins said, “although I myself have concerns.” After making his determination, the judge urged Bova to cooperate with his attorneys, and said that if Bova were “incapable” of doing so, “then I would reconsider my determination of competency in this case.”
Greg Jolley says
Brilliant and detailed coverage of this important case.
It looks to me like this guy needs a brain scan and a complete hormonal evaluation PRONTO. There is some organic process going on, obviously.
If this guy does not meet the criteria of insane, no one does… SMH
John R Brady says
Those eyes looks, to me, like what are called raccoon eyes usually the result of a blow above the bridge of the nose.
i worked for the sheriff’s office for many years, many shifts working the block Bova was housed in. He never received a blow to the bridge of his nose. This is caused by him being so dirty from not showering or taking care of his hygiene. When he was bathing and cleaning himself regularly, the swelling went down, and he looked normal, when he would stop bathing and was dirty, he would swell back up.
@ John R Brady – Joseph Bova eyes April 11, 2017 https://flaglerlive.com/106844/bova-threats/
His eyes get worst on April 30, 2019 https://flaglerlive.com/136189/joseph-bova-forcible/
And, you are saying it’s because of a blow above the bridge? I don’t think so!
One of the doctors who testified–Joseph Sesta, who considers him incompetent–said he could not explain the distorted face and had not seen it in his experience.
Zuheily was not only a close friend of mine and my family, but she was also my co worker. I stood there mere hours after this scum took her from this world. This case has dragged out far too long. I said it before and I’ll say it again. When a dog is rabid, acting crazy, and hurts someone you put it down. The same thing goes for this POS! For 6 years tax payer dollars have been spent sending him to hospitals and housing him in jail. When will enough be enough? When will the system finally stop all of this nonsense? It’s time this all came to an end and Zuheily’s family was finally able to get some type of closure.
One of the first things I”d check on this guy is his pituitary. But a Brain Scan seems like a no-brainer ( no pun intended.)
If this killer was ‘insane’ at the moment of the murder, then shouldn’t all those high school shooters be ruled insane too? Its obviously insane to take an innocent persons life, but they still must pay for it, and be removed from society.
Willy Boy says
Incredible amount of resources burned through on this, and there are years of appeals yet to go. Cruel justice for the victim, and all concerned.
I think the eyes are more like skunk eyes as this whole debacle stinks. What a waste of time, money & resources for this animal. He should suffer the same as his victim, execution style. So now who is the insane ones? SMH!
The old fake insane plea, some will do anything to stay our of prison and he is the perfect example of that.