No Bull, No Fluff, No Smudges
Your news source for
Flagler, Florida and Beyond

Court Appearance Adds to Puzzles Behind Mobil Mart Murder Suspect as Victim’s Mother Looks On

| December 3, 2013

Joseph Bova II on his way out of the courtroom Tuesday, with his attorney, Ray Warren, left, looking on. (© FlaglerLive)

Joseph Bova II on his way out of the courtroom Tuesday, with his attorney, Ray Warren, left, looking on. (© FlaglerLive)

When he was led in from the holding cell at the courthouse, to stand before Circuit Judge J. David Walsh for a brief pre-trail conference Tuesday afternoon, Joseph Bova bore a slight smile. And when he was escorted out less than six minutes later, he briefly looked over his shoulder at cameramen, his eyebrows raised as if inquisitively. He didn’t say anything for the duration of the conference, his first since his arrest. The pre-trial conference raised more puzzling questions than it answered.

Click On:

But that’s been the case since Bova was arrested in mid-September, while he was living in his car in Boca Raton, for the Feb. 21 murder of Roman Rosado as the mother of six young children worked the late shift at the Mobil Mart store on State Road 100 in Palm Coast. There is no motive for the execution-style murder, caught on a video surveillance camera and showing a man, his face covered, quickly pointing a gun at Rosado and firing. The man wore the exact same clothes and shoes as a man, believed to be Bova, who had entered the store earlier that evening, briefly looked around and headed to the ATM machine to withdraw cash. The gun used in the murder was traced to Bova who, according to police, said he’d always been in possession of the gun.

Bova has pleaded not guilty to a first-degree murder charge. If convicted, he may face the death penalty.

Members of Rosado’s family were in the audience, including her mother, Carmen Rosado, and her father, Jose Gonzales. Two of Roman’s children–her youngest, a toddler, and her second-oldest, Kaily Roman, who is 16, waited outside the courtroom.

Joseph Bova II as he was led into the courtroom. Click on the image for larger view. Click on the image for larger view. (© FlaglerLive)

Joseph Bova II as he was led into the courtroom. Click on the image for larger view. Click on the image for larger view. (© FlaglerLive)

“I almost didn’t recognized him, and he’s very skinny,” Carmen Rosado told reporters in Spanish afterward. “I am satisfied because I know that God has brought justice. God has put him in front of the judge, and the judge did what was needed to be done. He looks like he wasn’t doing well in jail. I don’t know if he knew her, I don’t know if he didn’t know her, and we don’t know why he did it. Why would he have killed her? He had no reason. And me of course, as a mother, I don’t understand it: if he didn’t know her, why would this happen? He didn’t know her, he didn’t know us. Why would he kill her? And if there was a reason, please, tell the judge so that we can know.”

At this stage of course the judge merely approved a continuance. Another pre-trial date was set for Feb. 4 because his attorney, Ray Warren, a public defender assigned to the case in place of private counsel that was previously disallowed, was not ready to go to trial yet. And there’s been a few issues with Bova in jail.

That private attorney “initiated a request for a psychological evaluation for either competency and or sanity, and I have seen the order that you entered on that, and this was a court order,” Warren told the judge. The doctor went to the jail to see Bova. Warren was there. Bova refused to see the doctor. Later that evening, after the doctor saw other inmates at the jail, he returned to Bova. Bova turned him down again.

“On three different occasions I’ve attempted to have medical releases signed,” Warren said. “I have been unsuccessful.”

Something also happened on Thanksgiving Day. As with so many things involving Bova, it’s cryptic. But it required an intervention, and it involved medical issues, which means that they may not even be released to his own attorney without Bova’s approval. Bova, so far, has refused to sign over the records. Just as he’s refused to see a doctor. His attorney is left to rely on hearsay. The incident, he told the judged, “involved some loss of control.”

Warren has been in contact with Bova’s father. But the suspect is talking to the attorney as well. “He has met with me on a number of occasions, so I can report that, but I am not ready for trial,” Warren said.

Judge Walsh asked Warren to schedule yet another appointment form the doctor to see Bova. Then, turning to Bova, Walsh said: “Mr. Bova, I’ll just make one comment, I would suggest that you speak with a doctor when he comes. It’s something that would be very important to your case, as I’m sure Mr. Warren would have discussed with you.”

Jaquelyn Roys, the prosecutor on the case, said Bova was violating a court by not meeting with the doctor. Walsh noted a nuance: “He may be meeting but the question of his speaking is the problem. So you have to converse with the doctor.”

Bova was then escorted out.

Speaking outside, the courtroom, Kaily Roman said that “on the way here I was kind of scared to see him.” The family, she said, is doing “better than we were doing before.” She was referring not only to the trauma of the murder itself, but to the dislocation of the family that followed, with just two children in Volusia County. Three are in Miami, her older sister in in Puerto Rico.

Carmen Rosado said of her daughter: “Although she is dead now, she’s not here with her mother and her children, I am happy with the justice system. God permitting this will become clear in one form or another. I am also appreciative of the help of God. I know that by one way or another, everything will be made whole.”

Erick Niemi, who faces a first-degree murder charge in the May 29 killing of Leonard Lynn, 76, his roommate at the time at their Ryken Lane home in Palm Coast, had also been scheduled for a sentencing today on a grand theft charge dating back to 2012, and for a pre-trial appearance on the murder charge. Both cases were continued today.

Print Friendly, PDF & Email

8 Responses for “Court Appearance Adds to Puzzles Behind Mobil Mart Murder Suspect as Victim’s Mother Looks On”

  1. NortonSmitty says:

    OK, so he ” headed to the ATM machine to withdraw cash.” His account? Whoever, this had to be the first thing investigated, as it is easily traceable and a firm link to the murderer. We need to know more.

  2. Anonymous says:

    This guy looks like he can’t decide whether he’s a tough guy or a member of the opposite sex. I don’t think he’ll have a very easy time of it in prison. For his own safety and/or to avoid constant disruption, they’ll have to isolate him soon enough.

  3. justice for Zuheily says:

    puzzle/ puzzle/ are you serious? puzzle is whats happened to the kids there was once a complete puzzle and now there are so many missing pieces its ridiculous!!! give me a break he has had a long enough chance to think what he has to say!! 7 months to be exact then today he gets another chance for time because they think he might be loco? cmon please he is no damn fool he is not crazy and this was a premeditated murder!! how can you be an indigent with a bank account? and a nice car too? zuheily was more poor than him and was doing an honest thing working to provide for her family why this hitman or whatever heis planned her murder!!

  4. barbie says:

    There are a lot of holes here, of course it’s a “puzzle”.

  5. confidential says:

    If Bova refuses to see a doctor and the doctor examination report is necessary to proceed with his case….then proceed without it…is costing us tax payers to keep this man in jail, while the expression in his face is one of laughing at us all. I wonder if Bova were a black man in the same situation Judge Walsh would have given his public appointed defender and Bova more time…Peculiar way to interpret and administer justice, specially on a case that I am personally convinced that was racially provoked in an environment where unprovoked bigots have free access to high power weapons.

  6. Florida Native. says:

    And then he copped an insanity plea and ended up in the state mental hospital with free medical,dental,internet,law library,air conditioning,heat and three squares a day. Write it down.

  7. jim reed says:

    I pray for this woman and her family. Such a senseless crime. He needs to go to trial and if guilty receive the death penalty.

  8. ryan says:

    This has nothing to do with race, so please confidential, don’t go there. It is an insult to those who have been victims of real racial violence. As for this sick person Bova, he needs to go to prison, and defense attys. across the nation need to stop raising an insanity plea in a slimy attempt to get their client off. If the client did it, and has informed their attorney they are guilty, the attorney needs to have some ethics and tell them to plead guilty. It is a true injustice to allow Bova to ever see freedom again.

Leave a Reply

FlaglerLive's forum, as noted in our comment policy, is for debate and conversation that adds light and perspective to articles. Please be courteous, don't attack fellow-commenters or make personal attacks against individuals in stories, and try to stick to the subject. All comments are moderated.

Read FlaglerLive's Comment Policy | Subscribe to the Comment Feed rss flaglerlive comment feed rss

More stories on FlaglerLive

FlaglerLive Email Alerts

Enter your email address to get alerts.


suppert flaglerlive flagler live palm coast flagler county news pierre tristam florida
fcir florida center for investigative reporting
FlaglerLive is a non-profit 501(c)(3) organization | P.O. Box 254263, Palm Coast, FL 32135 | Contact the Editor by email | (386) 586-0257 | Sitemap | Log in