No Bull, No Fluff, No Smudges
Your news source for
Flagler, Florida and Beyond

Showdown Over Local Control as State Aims to Stop Miami Beach From Raising Minimum Wage

| October 31, 2018

miami beach minimum wage

Miami Beach wants to go its own way with the minimum wage. The state wants to prevent it. (Gilles)

Attorney General Pam Bondi’s office and major business groups urged the Florida Supreme Court this week to prevent the city of Miami Beach from moving forward with a local minimum wage.

Bondi’s office and the business groups filed briefs arguing that the Supreme Court should uphold lower-court rulings that said a state law bars Miami Beach from gradually increasing its minimum wage to $13.31 an hour in 2021. The case also has drawn attention from local governments, which have sided with Miami Beach.

The legal battle stems, in part, from a 2004 voter-approved constitutional amendment that gave Florida a higher minimum wage than the federal rate. Bondi’s office and the business groups argue that another state law — known as a preemption law — effectively requires Florida’s minimum wage to be the same throughout the state and blocks local governments from passing higher rates.

“In sum, while it is clear that voters adopted a constitutional amendment providing for an inflation-indexed statewide minimum wage that is higher than the federal minimum wage, it is equally clear that the amendment does not alter the Legislature’s well-established, preexisting power to preempt local minimum wages under (another part of the state Constitution),” attorneys for the state wrote in a 54-page brief filed Monday. “Although the Legislature plainly cannot undercut the constitutionally mandated minimum wage, it is free to prohibit local governments from enacting higher minimum wages.”

Miami Beach approved an ordinance in 2016 that called for the minimum wage to be set at $10.31 an hour this year and incrementally increase to $13.31 an hour in 2021. The statewide minimum wage is $8.25 an hour, while the federal minimum wage is $7.25 an hour.

Business groups and Bondi’s office challenged the Miami Beach ordinance and won in circuit court and the 3rd District Court of Appeal. That led Miami Beach to go to the Supreme Court, which decided by a 4-3 vote in August to take up the case. The Supreme Court has not scheduled oral arguments.

In a brief filed in September, Miami Beach attorneys said the drive to pass the 2004 constitutional amendment began after state lawmakers in 2003 approved a measure to preempt local minimum wages. The brief said passage of the constitutional amendment reflected a “deliberate intent of the voters to reject the ceiling imposed by the preemption statute and, instead, to create a locally improvable floor as the minimum wage paradigm of the state of Florida.”

“In 2004, in direct response to the preemption statute, the people passed the minimum wage amendment that raised the minimum wage in Florida and explicitly stated that it did not preempt any local minimum wage ordinances and did not preempt ordinances requiring payment of a minimum wage by employers, or to employees,” the brief said.

But attorneys for the business groups, including the Florida Retail Federation, the Florida Restaurant & Lodging Association and the Florida Chamber of Commerce, disputed those arguments. In part, the business groups said the 2004 constitutional amendment did not “explicitly repeal” the preemption law and, as a result, the “two provisions must stand and operate together.”

“The (Supreme) Court need only look at the express language in the amendment and (the preemption law) to determine that their provisions can be read together without contradiction,” the business groups argued in their brief filed Monday. “There is no question that the amendment does not expressly prohibit the state Legislature from passing legislation that restricts the ability of local governments to enact minimum wages higher than the state wage.”  

–Jim Saunders, News Service of Florida

6 Responses for “Showdown Over Local Control as State Aims to Stop Miami Beach From Raising Minimum Wage”

  1. Rhonda says:

    Another example of our present Florida legislature working hard to take away local control. Don’t let big businesses and the politicians in their pockets control our communities from Tallahassee.

    Vote them out! That’s my plan.

  2. Dave says:

    They dont want us making more money? What kind of a State would try to keep their people down on purpose? Why would they want our people to not make more money? This is disturbing indeed

  3. Pogo says:

    @W-2 wage earners – and all other self-respecting human beings

    Voting for a Republican makes less sense than a chicken voting for Col. Sanders.

    Vote Blue as if your life, health and future depend upon it. They do.

  4. Palmcoaster says:

    This is the FL legislature controlled by supermajority GOP (Greedy Opulent People …of today) under their current Governor and Pam Bondi! They want to keep our workers with meager pay, no benefits and no unions to defend them. In few words if you are poor we want you to stay that way. This why we need change. Is so deceiving to call these southern states with their anti union labor laws “The right to work states” I will add for part time jobs, minimum wages and no benefits (vacation, sick days or health care insurance). That promotes that our workers show up for work sick as they can’t afford their medical or miss pay days and specially in winter we can see in restaurants workers or groceries registers them working with a cold, etc.
    We also can learn of tragedies right here in our county of a young American man ending up loosing a limb over not affording medical insurance and get medical attention in time at the first bad symptom…so these GOP’s smart ones now force us all and rightfully for the victim, to sustain him as a disable young American wheel chair bounded. Would’t have been more humane that this young man would have had his health care “for all” taken care in time not to suffer the devastation of loosing a limb and be 100 percent able to make a living now? I also pay taxes and I strongly believe that we are to help our own fellow Americans fallen in difficult times to no fault of their own as well and we should start with our workers. So if wealthy Mecca tourist Miami wants to increase its minimum wage why not?

  5. Sherry says:

    Ahhhhh. . . just another example of favoring the “profits of businesses”, over the actual life blood of “working citizens”!!

  6. Nancy N says:

    Dave – The simple answer to your question is – the kind of State that works for big business, not the people.

    Just another example of Republicans who advocate for local control – except when it goes against their donors’ interests.

Leave a Reply

FlaglerLive's forum, as noted in our comment policy, is for debate and conversation that adds light and perspective to articles. Please be courteous, don't attack fellow-commenters or make personal attacks against individuals in stories, and try to stick to the subject. All comments are moderated.

Read FlaglerLive's Comment Policy | Subscribe to the Comment Feed rss flaglerlive comment feed rss

More stories on FlaglerLive

FlaglerLive Email Alerts

Enter your email address to get alerts.


support flaglerlive palm coast flagler county news pierre tristam
news service of florida
FlaglerLive is a non-profit 501(c)(3) organization | P.O. Box 254263, Palm Coast, FL 32135 | Contact the Editor by email | (386) 586-0257 | Sitemap | Log in