By Diane Roberts
The moms of Moms for “Liberty” are feeling a little touchy, put-upon, even diminished.
Their do-boy DeSantis crashed out of the presidential race like a drunk out of a second story saloon.
They’re losing school board elections.
They’re making idiots of themselves in the national media. Check out this MSNBC interview in which Moms co-founder Tiffany Justice simultaneously defends taking books off school library shelves while denying that Moms want books taken off school library shelves, unless they’re by Black writers or gay writers, or ones dealing with the Holocaust, coming out, sexual violence, racism, and good old heterosexual whoopee.
Justice and her sister suburban harpies claim they want to protect children’s “innocence.”
For months now they’ve been forced to defend themselves against charges of rank hypocrisy: Bridget Ziegler, another Moms co-founder and member of the Sarasota County School Board, likes the odd three-way with her husband, former Florida GOP chair Christian Ziegler, and another woman.
We know this because 1. Bridget admitted it; 2. Christian filmed it.
The Moms keep frantically trying to distance themselves from Bridget, insisting she officially left the group in January 2021, and no, they don’t approve of her exotic proclivities.
Nevertheless, Bridget Z. remains one of their most high-profile champions, pushing book bans, embracing DeSantis’ “Don’t Say Gay Law,” and attacking trans people.
Sarasotans wish she would go away: “You have emotionally and psychologically damaged countless students, parents, and teachers with your hateful rhetoric,” said one man at a school board meeting. “Resign.”
But Bridget refuses to resign from the school board or from her perch on DeSantis’ hand-picked Disney oversight board.
Christian’s been canned; somebody’s got to make a living.
Evils of Social Studies
Still, though the luster may be coming off those clutch-able pearls, the Moms haven’t stopped fighting unionized teachers pushing inconvenient facts that may lead to actual thinking.
The menace du jour? Social studies.
The Duval County Moms chapter is pitching a hissy fit over what they call “government schools” teaching children to be “activists.”
The lessons they object to include such basic civics as “Good citizens learn about their community,” maybe “think about problems that need to be solved” and “go to community meetings and talk about issues.”
Shocking!
Funny thing, though: The Moms would surely admit they created their organization after thinking about problems they thought needed to be solved, and decided they’d go to community meetings to talk (or in their case, shout) about issues.
Social studies explore how history, culture, civics, values, economics, and the arts help shape our society; the discipline is foundational to functioning as an informed citizen in a democracy.
But the Moms don’t like democracy and they don’t like any academic subject that might challenge the religion of American exceptionalism.
Have a look at the Duval Moms’ twixxter page: a festival of white paranoia, misinformation, and transphobia. One scandalized poster blasts Michelle Obama for helping to lead an organization that helps eligible high schoolers register to vote.
Like Taylor Swift, Michelle Obama is a clearly radical operative working to destroy the nation.
The Moms work like a genteel Stasi, passing damning “information” on enemy teachers and “liberal” school boards to their most important ally, the state of Florida.
The state also hates social studies.
Education Commissioner Manny Diaz Jr. has been particularly energetic in reducing public school social studies to white nationalist propaganda.
Your moment of irony: Manny Diaz was once a social studies teacher.
‘Politically charged’
In a unit on American symbols, one elementary school textbook had said that while the convention is for people to stand during the national anthem, a teacher might “take this opportunity to talk about why some citizens are choosing to ‘take a knee’ to protest police brutality and racism.”
That language is gone.
Another lesson about Judeo-Christian influence on western civilization included the discussion question: “What social justice issues are included in the Hebrew Bible?” and suggests the Bible “includes guidelines for responding to poverty, famine, and injustice; it emphasizes respecting human life, giving generously, caring for strangers and refugees, and respecting property.”
The state objected to the phrase “social justice” — seems it’s “politically charged,” unfit for students, and must be erased.
The Moms congratulate themselves on their success in censoring and bowdlerizating materials that might suggest the world is complex, not always pleasant, and rarely simple, as well as any suggestion that America is not the best nation there ever was.
The kids may struggle with gender and race but can’t read books that deal with gender and race. The kids may wonder why racism persists in a country that never shuts up about “freedom” and “equality,” but they won’t be taught how the legacy of slavery and Jim Crow still haunts our institutions.
DoE deemed a lesson on how the killing of George Floyd and other instances of police violence against Black people sparked “a growing awareness of systemic racism” and led to the formation of Black Lives Matter.
The material did not take a side, pro- or con BLM, pointing out that some protests became violent and many Americans disagreed over whether the police needed to reform.
The language was factual, but that didn’t matter. DoE didn’t even bother to edit it: They just deleted the whole unit.
That’s what the Moms want. A void where facts used to be.
Minefield of wokeness
They object to the novels of Judy Blume and Toni Morrison, as well as innocuous books such as “Martin Luther King and the March on Washington” and “Ruby Bridges Goes to School” (about the first Black child to integrate an all-white New Orleans school in 1960), claiming those texts teach Critical Race Theory.
Moms couldn’t define Critical Race Theory if their lives depended on it. They just know it has the word “race” in it.
They would prefer white children to be clueless about race, from how this country formed itself on the labor of enslaved Africans to segregation to redlining.
Now it’s Black History Month, a minefield of wokeness, and the Moms are nervous.
Top Mom Tina Descovich sounded the alarm about a Black Lives Matter “Week of Action” curriculum some schools might use in February.
BLM’s suggested topics include “Empathy,” Loving Engagement,” and “Diversity,” but also “Trans-Affirming,” “Queer Affirming,” and “Black Villages,” which suggests that the nuclear family is not the only way to raise children.
In case those words didn’t sufficiently terrorize white parents, Descovich posted a photo of a Black person in a hoodie, fist raised.
Not very subtle, is she?
But the DeSantis regime and its frightened white supporters don’t value subtlety. Or consistency, integrity, or truth.
This is a state in which Republicans want to raise the age to become a stripper and lower the age to buy a rifle, ban abortion from the moment of fertilization, turn our universities into conservative re-education camps, and make our schools patriotic indoctrination centers.
The Moms are all in.
Diane Roberts is an 8th-generation Floridian, born and bred in Tallahassee. Educated at Florida State University and Oxford University in England, she has been writing for newspapers since 1983, when she began producing columns on the legislature for the Florida Flambeau. Her work has appeared in the New York Times, the Times of London, the Guardian, the Washington Post, the Oxford American, and Flamingo. She has been a member of the Editorial Board of the St. Petersburg Times–back when that was the Tampa Bay Times’s name–and a long-time columnist for the paper in both its iterations. She was a commentator on NPR for 22 years and continues to contribute radio essays and opinion pieces to the BBC. Roberts is also the author of four books.
Endless dark money says
This is the gop way. Name it ” for liberty” while taking away liberty and our supporters too dumb to realize the hypocrisy. There are lots of examples of this. Look up pretty much any repulicon or “conservative “organization.
Awake says
The most stupid thing about these book bans is the fact that most kids, teenagers, etc. don’t even read unless the book is assigned to them and they are forced. Even though I’m old, I still remember being in school and no one read but a very few of us. We would read no matter how many book bans they devised. Those of us who were/are readers will find ways to read these books and those who aren’t readers or who don’t care, won’t read anything that isn’t forced upon them anyway.
The Morons of Less Liberty Moms would rather their children be thrust into the adult world completely unprepared and uneducated to the way life is. They’d rather them read books on how to put ridiculous fake eyelashes on, how to make a duck face, how to find just the perfect pair of strategically ripped jeans to wear, how to use their smart phones while driving down the road, how to keep those homeless people out of their neighborhoods, how to live life with no empathy for anyone or anything, how to ban those oh so scary LGBT people, and how to run for cover when the shooting starts.
That last item is perhaps the most important thing to learn in our current political climate – (climate of course being a bad word in this Putinesque state) since we would rather fight over abortion and lower the gun age because we all know it’s those “baby killing” pro-choice people who are dangerous, not some alienated whacko with a gun. Perhaps instead of teaching Social Studies, we could substitute books on how to be a Barbie doll.
Sam says
Stop the discriminating and treat everyone equally. The World would be a better place. Leave books up to who wants to read them and what they want to read. Stop taking freedom rights from people.
Enough says
I wonder what kind of childhood these ‘Moms” had that has made them present themselves as hateful, ignorant and vengeful people. They claim to want to protect children’s “innocence”, but at the same time, denying them the right to learn about diversity. And we all know that diversity exists throughout the world: different religious beliefs, different skin colors, different languages, and so on.
What are they trying to protect them from? The FACTS that made this country grow throughout the decades!!
Can one imagine the reaction if these “kids” leave Florida, are faced with numerous culture “shocks” from a job accepted in a major city? Would they be prepared to not only accept different peers, but to accept the reality that these people actually exist in a culture that they never learned. They become the “odd man out” and most likely will be cast aside as the “strange” one.
As is typical with this group, and our “illustrious” governor, it appears that actions should be taken first, and then worry about the consequences later. There is no foresight in determining what harm will come from frivolous decision making.
I am not against children being kept away from things that can harm them; reading a book is NOT one of them. But forcing fanatical groups like “Moms for Liberty” is!!
Laurel says
Enough: You may recall that DeSantis wanted to make America Florida. It’s all about control and power.
rapscallion says
I’m borrowing a line from a recent article from The Atlantic
“Groups on each side of the political divide are held together less by common affections than by a common sense of threat”
Has to be a struggle going through life afraid.
Inshallah
Michael J Cocchiola says
Let’s call the Mommies For Lunacy what it is… a hateful racist, misogynist group of fascists. This group is evil and an affront to all that Christianity and America purport to stand for. They pollute our media and our senses. When the last of them crawls back under the manure pile we should have a national “book day” and break out all of the banned books for a collective reading.
And I will lead a collective piss on the manure pile.
Willy James says
Collectively, I would say that the Mom’s for Liberty have the IQ of a flys ass!
Laurel says
What’s really bothersome to me (a native Floridian who loves her state) is that these wack-a-doo groups may be attracting more like minded wack-a-doos here, and more normal folks are leaving Florida. More and more sane, moderate Republicans are leaving Congress which leaves more openings for the crazies like MfL types. We need moderate Republicans to stay, and moderate Republicans to take their party back from the current clown show. We need both sides to work together, across the isle, not extreme far right, and not extreme far left, and actually start getting things done that are really important. Not this constant, threatening foolishness.
I can’t wait for this nonsense to pass.
Deborah Coffey says
Don’t ever leave us, Diane. You’re the best at completely capturing our thoughts and feelings…though I must say…the comments here have matched your talent. If Michael Cocchiola leads, I will follow.
Stephen says
Is it still Moms for Liberty or Moms for threesomes?