• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
MENUMENU
MENUMENU
  • Home
  • About
    • Contact Us
    • FlaglerLive Board of Directors
    • Comment Policy
    • Mission Statement
    • Our Values
  • Live Calendar
  • Submit Obituary
  • Submit an Event
  • Support FlaglerLive
  • Advertise on FlaglerLive (386) 503-3808
  • Search Results

FlaglerLive

No Bull, no Fluff, No Smudges

MENUMENU
  • Flagler
    • Flagler County Commission
    • Beverly Beach
    • Economic Development Council
    • Flagler History
    • Mondex/Daytona North
    • The Hammock
    • Tourist Development Council
  • Palm Coast
    • Palm Coast City Council
    • Palm Coast Crime
  • Bunnell
    • Bunnell City Commission
    • Bunnell Crime
  • Flagler Beach
    • Flagler Beach City Commission
    • Flagler Beach Crime
  • Cops/Courts
    • Circuit & County Court
    • Florida Supreme Court
    • Federal Courts
    • Flagler 911
    • Fire House
    • Flagler County Sheriff
    • Flagler Jail Bookings
    • Traffic Accidents
  • Rights & Liberties
    • Fourth Amendment
    • First Amendment
    • Privacy
    • Second Amendment
    • Seventh Amendment
    • Sixth Amendment
    • Sunshine Law
    • Third Amendment
    • Religion & Beliefs
    • Human Rights
    • Immigration
    • Labor Rights
    • 14th Amendment
    • Civil Rights
  • Schools
    • Adult Education
    • Belle Terre Elementary
    • Buddy Taylor Middle
    • Bunnell Elementary
    • Charter Schools
    • Daytona State College
    • Flagler County School Board
    • Flagler Palm Coast High School
    • Higher Education
    • Imagine School
    • Indian Trails Middle
    • Matanzas High School
    • Old Kings Elementary
    • Rymfire Elementary
    • Stetson University
    • Wadsworth Elementary
    • University of Florida/Florida State
  • Economy
    • Jobs & Unemployment
    • Business & Economy
    • Development & Sprawl
    • Leisure & Tourism
    • Local Business
    • Local Media
    • Real Estate & Development
    • Taxes
  • Commentary
    • The Conversation
    • Pierre Tristam
    • Diane Roberts
    • Guest Columns
    • Byblos
    • Editor's Blog
  • Culture
    • African American Cultural Society
    • Arts in Palm Coast & Flagler
    • Books
    • City Repertory Theatre
    • Flagler Auditorium
    • Flagler Playhouse
    • Flagler Youth Orchestra
    • Jacksonville Symphony Orchestra
    • Palm Coast Arts Foundation
    • Special Events
  • Elections 2022
    • Amendments and Referendums
    • Presidential Election
    • Campaign Finance
    • City Elections
    • Congressional
    • Constitutionals
    • Courts
    • Governor
    • Polls
    • Voting Rights
  • Florida
    • Federal Politics
    • Florida History
    • Florida Legislature
    • Florida Legislature
    • Ron DeSantis
  • Health & Society
    • Flagler County Health Department
    • Ask the Doctor Column
    • Health Care
    • Health Care Business
    • Covid-19
    • Children and Families
    • Medicaid and Medicare
    • Mental Health
    • Poverty
    • Violence
  • All Else
    • Daily Briefing
    • Americana
    • Obituaries
    • News Briefs
    • Weather and Climate
    • Wildlife

In 5-2 Ruling, Florida Supreme Court Rejects Ballot Measure Banning Federal Health Reform

August 31, 2010 | FlaglerLive | 1 Comment

supreme court of florida
The foolery stops here. (Steven Martin)


Jim Saunders
Health News Florida

The Florida Supreme Court on Tuesday rejected a proposed constitutional amendment that targeted the new federal-health reform law, ruling that state lawmakers included misleading wording that could not be fixed.

Justices, in a 5-2 ruling, upheld a circuit judge’s decision to strip “Amendment 9” from the November ballot. The court rejected state arguments that it could simply eliminate a ballot summary that included the disputed wording and let the rest of the proposal go before voters.


Click On:

  • Read the Full Decision
  • Supreme Court Still Silent on Proposal to Exclude Floridians From Federal Health Reform
  • Florida 1 of 3 States With Top-Rated Medicare Advantage Plan. But You Can’t Enroll in Flagler.
  • Feds, Not Florida, Will Pay for Medicaid’s 1 Million New Beneficiaries


“In this case, the ballot language put forth by the party proposing the constitutional amendment contains misleading and ambiguous language,” the main court opinion said. “Currently, our only recourse is to strike the proposed constitutional amendment from the ballot, thereby removing it from a vote of the electorate.”

The decision outraged Rep. Scott Plakon, a Longwood Republican who helped sponsor the proposed constitutional amendment during the spring legislative session. He vowed to bring back a revised proposal next year with the goal of putting it on the 2012 ballot.

“We will make adjustments, and I will be filing it on the first day we can file bills,” Plakon said.

The Republican-controlled Legislature approved Amendment 9 primarily as an effort to allow people to opt out of a new federal requirement that they eventually buy health insurance or face financial penalties. In part, the proposal called for Floridians to not be forced by law to “participate in any health-care system.”

But four voters filed a lawsuit to challenge wording in a ballot summary that voters would see when they go to the polls. Leon County Circuit Judge Judge James O. Shelfer agreed with their arguments last month, describing the wording as “manifestly misleading” and tossing the amendment off the ballot.

The disputed summary wording said the amendment would “ensure access to health-care services without waiting lists, protect the doctor-patient relationship (and) guard against mandates that don’t work.” Shelfer said those broad claims were not backed up in the actual text of the amendment, which voters typically would not see when they cast ballots.

During Supreme Court arguments, an attorney for the state did not defend the wording. Instead, he asked the court to simply eliminate the ballot summary and put the full text of the amendment on the ballot — a move that justices made in 2004 on another disputed ballot proposal.

But the court rejected that argument Tuesday, with Justices Peggy Quince, Jorge Labarga and James E.C. Perry signing an opinion that specifically said the 2004 opinion was” not consistent with a long line of cases involving proposed constitutional amendments.”

“Our role in this process is as a reviewer of constitutional validity, not as an editor or author,” the opinion said.

Justices Barbara Pariente and Fred Lewis also agreed to reject Amendment 9, though they did not sign onto the main opinion. Chief Justice Charles Canady and Justice Ricky Polston dissented.

Canady wrote an opinion saying the court should follow the lead of the 2004 case and the Legislature’s desire for voters to cast ballots on Amendment 9.

“Whenever the Legislature proposes a constitutional amendment, it is overwhelmingly clear that the Legislature‘s objective is to give the people an opportunity to vote on the proposed amendment,” Canady wrote. “Placing the full text of the proposed amendment on the ballot would undeniably be consistent with that objective. Failing to place the full text on the ballot undeniably defeats that objective.”

Plakon particularly criticized Quince, Pariente and Lewis, who allowed the 2004 amendment — which dealt with parental notification of abortion — to go on the ballot but rejected Amendment 9.

“These three judges, it’s outrageous on their part,” he said. “It’s just an outrageous judicial power grab.”

But Mark Herron, an attorney for the four voters who challenged the amendment, said justices can’t simply eliminate wording approved by the Legislature.

“The courts just don’t have the power to rewrite amendments,” he said.

Health News Florida Capital Bureau Chief Jim Saunders can be reached at 850-228-0963 or by e-mail.

Print Friendly, PDF & Email
You and your neighbors collectively read our articles about 25,000 times each day (that's not a typo) with up to 65,000 daily reads during emergencies like hurricanes. Flagler County residents rely on FlaglerLive for essential, bold and analytical journalism that cannot be found anywhere else. But we depend on your support. Please join our December fund drive! If you donate the cost of a scoop of ice cream, you will be helping us continue to provide comprehensive local news and honest, serious journalism for our community. If you can donate more or become a monthly donor, even better. Donations are tax deductible since FlaglerLive is a 501(c)(3) non-profit news organization. Donate by clicking anywhere in this box. Think of it as buying a scoop, in every sense of the term!  
All donors' identities are kept confidential and anonymous.
   

Reader Interactions

Comments

  1. emile says

    September 2, 2010 at 12:59 pm

    It’s nice to see that our Florida Supremes don’t plan on rewriting amendments. How can this be considered a Judicial power grab?

    Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Primary Sidebar

Advertisers

  • grand living realty
  • politis matovina attorneys for justice personal injury law auto truck accidents
  • WNZF Creekside Festival

Recent Comments

  • Been There on Florida’s Policing of Public Restroom Gender Draws Federal Lawsuit from Trans and Nonbinary Group
  • Been There on Bible Challenge in Flagler Schools Unravels Inconsistencies, Arbitrariness and Confusion in Review Process
  • Wow on Flagler School Board Wants ‘Standing’ Closed-Door Meetings Every 3 Months. That Would Be Illegal.
  • JimboXYZ on Flagler School Board Wants ‘Standing’ Closed-Door Meetings Every 3 Months. That Would Be Illegal.
  • Jane on Flagler School Board Wants ‘Standing’ Closed-Door Meetings Every 3 Months. That Would Be Illegal.
  • Maria on Flagler School Board Wants ‘Standing’ Closed-Door Meetings Every 3 Months. That Would Be Illegal.
  • Annie Pledge-Oddo on Palm Coast Farmers’ Market at European Village
  • Mary Jane on Sally Hunt Raises Questions About Using Schools as Shelters During Hurricane Emergencies
  • steve on DeSantis Solution to Climate Change: Burn More Fossil Fuels
  • Roy on Sally Hunt Raises Questions About Using Schools as Shelters During Hurricane Emergencies
  • ban the GOP on DeSantis Solution to Climate Change: Burn More Fossil Fuels
  • Treeman on DeSantis Solution to Climate Change: Burn More Fossil Fuels
  • Nephew Of Uncle Sam on DeSantis Solution to Climate Change: Burn More Fossil Fuels
  • Ben Hogarth on DeSantis Solution to Climate Change: Burn More Fossil Fuels
  • Pogo on The Daily Cartoon and Live Briefing: Monday, October 2, 2023
  • Someone on Sally Hunt Raises Questions About Using Schools as Shelters During Hurricane Emergencies

Log in