By Craig Pittman
Last week, lots of people were tee-heeing or tsk-tsking about the Florida Department of Transportation taking down the old “Welcome to Florida” signs (or “WTF” for short). The DOT then put up new state line signs saying, “Welcome to the Free State of Florida.”
Free — to do what, exactly? Drive reeeeeally fast because you’re late for work? Go three miles with your left turn signal on and then turn right? Flip off the guy who cut you off in traffic and then hold your breath while you wait to see whether he’s armed?
When a reporter asked Lt. Gov. Jeanette Nuñez about the signs, she started blabbering about abortion — not the first thing you think of when you see a highway sign.
“We believe that we provide freedom, freedom to right to life, of course for those babies,” she said. Freedom of choice for women is apparently not a consideration here, which prompts me to ask: If the pro-abortion constitutional amendment passes this fall, will the Florida DOT take down the new signs and put the old ones back up?
In case you’re wondering, the signs themselves were definitely not free. They cost us taxpayers $60,000, according to WJXT-TV. In other words, they’re just like Gov. Ron “I’m Speaking at the RNC Because I Finally Kissed Trump’s Uhhhh Ring” DeSantis’ migrant flights. They’re just another state-sponsored stunt to “own the libs” with the bill paid by people who weren’t asking for even a short-term rental of the libs.
I recently heard about another Florida DOT political stunt that’s even kookier than these dopey signs.
Under part of the poorly named Bipartisan Infrastructure Law that Congress passed in 2021, Florida is slated to receive $198 million over five years from the National Electric Vehicle Infrastructure Formula Program.
“The program is designed to expand the nation’s fast-charging network by adding more chargers within a mile of interstates, helping EV drivers travel greater distances without the ‘range anxiety’ of getting stranded on a dead battery,” the Tampa Bay Times reported last month. “Businesses that receive the funding get enough to cover about 80% of the costs of installing the chargers and must put up the other 20%.”
Florida submitted a plan for spending the money, and the federal government approved it. But now Florida is one of 15 states that won’t allow any companies to apply for the money. Of those, Florida is the biggest state dragging its feet.
Turns out this delay is not your typical case of bureaucrats moving slower than a three-toed sloth climbing a greased pole in a driving rainstorm. They’re doing this on purpose.
Instead of handing out those federal millions, the Florida DOT has set up a silly website called “Roads Are Not For Politics.” Contrary to its name, the site features a laundry list of culture-war complaints, such as “COVID tyranny,” as well as criticism of electric vehicles. [See: “Palm Coast and County Snub Role in EV Charging Stations In Shocking Rebuff to a Green Energy Grant” and “Ed Danko Attacks City Staffer With Baseless Claims in Public Meeting, Drawing Sharp Rebuke from Mayor.”]
DOT Secretary Jared Perdue gets featured in a lot of the rhetoric, making blustery statements like, “Florida will continue to stand up for our freedoms and ensure Federal Green New Deal initiatives don’t impact Floridians.” I think the “ha-rumph” is implied.
I read about this weird situation last week in a publication called “Inside EVs” that — unlike the Times — managed to pry a comment out of the Florida DOT’s spokesman, Michael Williams.
“Free enterprise, not federal mandates, are the driving force when any industry experiences growth,” said Williams. He’s apparently unaware of who built the interstate highways, which fueled the trucking industry, not to mention who built the space program, which boosted the people making instant breakfast drinks.
“Nothing prohibits the private sector from building out our nation’s charging network, he sniffed. “With the total number of EVs on the road today constituting approximately 1% of all vehicles registered across the nation, ‘low consumer demand’ is an accurate statement.”
There’s one big problem with that last statement: People in Florida loooove EVs, and I mean A LOT. In fact, Florida now has more than 168,000 registered EVs — the second highest number in the nation. That’s quite a jump from 58,000 in 2021.
You know what we don’t have here?
Enough places to plug them in.
Kings of the road
Believe it or not, electric cars seemed like the wave of the future in the late 1800s. Ferdinand Porsche built one in 1898. Thomas Edison, a part-time Florida resident, thought electric vehicles were the superior technology of the day and worked to make a better battery.
But then, in 1908, Henry Ford — Edison’s neighbor in Fort Myers — started mass-producing the Model T, which sold for far less than other cars. They swept the nation, killing the demand for electric vehicles. Fossil-fueled vehicles became kings of the road, spewing nasty emissions everywhere and stimulating the polluting oil and gas industry.
To quote country singer Jerry Reed, “Lord, Mr. Ford, I just wish that you could see what your simple horseless carriage has become.”
Ninety years later, though, EVs made a comeback. Toyota introduced the world’s first mass-produced hybrid electric vehicle, the Prius. Other manufacturers followed. Slowly, the iron grip of gas-powered vehicle makers on the auto industry loosened.
The higher the price for a gallon of gas climbs, the more attractive EVs become. In 2020, Consumer Reports classified EVs as an overall better value than conventional cars. Reliable and sensibly priced cars are especially important for working folks in Florida, which has terrible mass transit (unless you count the Disney World shuttles).
The sitting president is obviously a big fan of them, since he pushed this pro-EV law through, plus another billion for converting idled auto factories to make more EVs.
His political rival, the smelly Palm Beach club owner who’s a convicted felon, hates them almost as much as he hates New York prosecutors. He has sworn he will kick them all to the curb.
“You’re not going to be able to sell those cars,” he said at one of his rallies. I’m sure his hostility has nothing to do with his plea to oil company executives to donate big bucks to his campaign.
He’s so opposed to EVs that it’s as if he’s the anti-Edison. He’s even ranted about other forms of EV transportation: “They want electric army tanks. They want electric planes. What happens if the sun isn’t shining while you’re up in the air?”
Heck, if someone invented the Jetsons’ flying car that folds up into a briefcase, he’d probably complain about the weight of the briefcase.
Once around the block
All the overheated political rhetoric left me feeling a little woozy, so I took a walk around my neighborhood to clear my head.
It’s a quiet, middle-class enclave. My neighbors include artists, teachers, and civil servants. One drives a Hummer, but I also spotted some EVs.
I talked to one of the EV owners. She bought her Tesla five years ago (before we all found out Elon Musk is such a billionaire bonehead).
“I bought it because I wanted to do my part to reduce emissions, but also because I think they’re really fun to drive,” she told me. When I asked her to explain, she said, “It’s got tremendous pickup. There are no gears, so you just push the pedal down and you’re flying.”
The one drawback, she said, was “range anxiety” — being afraid she’ll run out of power when she travels to certain parts of Florida where chargers are scarce. That’s a legitimate concern. Yet the Florida DOT is refusing to hand out federal money to fix that problem — money Florida taxpayers paid to the IRS.
“If Florida doesn’t use the money to build out charging infrastructure, then DeSantis is in essence cheating his own state’s residents of getting something in return for their tax payments,” Loren McDonald, CEO of analytics firm EVAdoption, told Inside EVs. Instead, we’re paying for the chargers in other states.
Plus, this federal investment would be good for Florida’s economy.
“Federal funding creates an opportunity for Florida’s taxpayers, workers, and drivers by helping EV infrastructure development keep up with demand for electric vehicles,” Sydney Timm of the advocacy group Drive Electric Florida told me. “Florida was allocated almost $200 million …, the third-most of any state, and the 20% cost share requirement can help to spur additional private investment.”
Yet those millions of dollars just sit there, unused. There’s a page on the Florida DOT website that describes the federal grant program, but it merely says, “Please monitor site for any updates.” So far, there aren’t any.
Feeling strongly both ways
You know who’s been in favor of boosting the number of chargers to keep up with the rising EV demand here?
None other than our own pudding-loving chief executive.
In 2020, DeSantis touted an $8.6 million state investment to “provide accessible electric vehicle infrastructure while also protecting air quality and expanding the state’s charging stations by 50% along most traveled corridors.” That money came from the feds too, from a settlement with VW for violations of the Clean Air Act.
Hard to believe that’s the same politician who, in the press release unveiling the anti-EV website, said, “Unlike the federal government, under my leadership Florida’s Department of Transportation is focused solely on transportation. We listen to Floridians and meet their needs. Roads are not for politics.”
(Everyone who suffered through the Unnecessary Toll Roads Built to Help Developers Era of DeSantis’ time in office knows better.)
Inside EVs pointed out that the Florida DOT even produced “a robust EV Infrastructure Master Plan in 2021 that anticipated aggressive growth and a network of chargers to serve it.”
Meanwhile, the Florida DOT has been trumpeting the installation of more charging stations. An undated press release on its website is headlined, “Florida’s Turnpike Amps Up the Voltage.”
“Multiple companies, including Tesla, Florida Power & Light, and Duke Energy, are involved with installing charging stations at the eight Florida’s Turnpike Service Plazas,” The press release says. “Faster EV chargers, called EV Level 3, are being installed up and down Florida’s Turnpike, as part of Gov. Ron DeSantis’ plan to create a more robust network of charging stations along the state’s highway system.”
Why would Florida’s DOT be so happy about that? “The increase in charging stations promotes reduced emissions and better air quality, while improving mobility and safety for the growing number of Floridians that drive electric cars,” explains the press release.
Does it seem to you that when it comes to EVs, DeSantis and his highway people are talking out of both sides of their mouths? Perhaps, like Billy Martin in the beer commercial used to say, they feel strongly BOTH ways.
Or perhaps what matters most to them is not where the money comes from, but who’s spending it.
Not so free after all
What cleared this up for me was a chat with Ryan McKinnon of the Charge Ahead Partnership.
The partnership maintains a low profile, but you’ve probably heard of some of its members: Wawa, Buc-ee’s, and Busy Bee. Their coalition, he said, “is made up of gas stations, convenience stores, and business owners who want to get into EV charging.”
They’re the ones who would benefit from Florida distributing that federal EV charger money. Their main issue, he told me, is “pushing back against utility ownership of EV charging stations.”
The problem, he said, is they “can’t compete when regulated utilities raise rates on all their customers to fund utility-owned and branded charging stations.”
He called this “a huge issue in Florida” because the utilities are so powerful. In fact, the nation’s largest utility-owned EV charging network belongs to <drumroll please> Florida Power & Light.
“FDOT’s website makes clear that Florida values the free market,” he told me. “Unfortunately, while sitting on [federal] funds that would help small businesses get their start in EV charging, the state has also allowed powerful electric utilities like Florida Power & Light to use ratepayer funds to build, own, and operate its own EV charging network, further discouraging free market competition.”
In other words, it’s not that Florida state government is battling the Evil Biden Green Agenda. It’s that the DeSantis administration is genuflecting toward Juno Beach, home of the almighty FPL. If they hand out those millions from the feds, Wawa might become a competitor to the utilities.
Hmmm, maybe the Florida DOT should take down those new signs. Doesn’t sound like we’re so “free” after all.
Craig Pittman is a native Floridian. In 30 years at the Tampa Bay Times, he won numerous state and national awards for his environmental reporting. He is the author of six books, including the New York Times bestseller Oh, Florida! How America’s Weirdest State Influences the Rest of the Country, which won a gold medal from the Florida Book Awards. His latest, published in 2021, is The State You’re In: Florida Men, Florida Women, and Other Wildlife. In 2020 the Florida Heritage Book Festival named him a Florida Literary Legend. Craig is co-host of the “Welcome to Florida” podcast. He lives in St. Petersburg with his wife and children.
Florida Mike says
President Biden is spending $7.5 billion to build EV charging infrastructure. The $7.5 billion in funding is enough for approximately 20,000 charging points but so far only 7 stations have opened from his “National Electric Vehicle Infrastructure” program, turning the program into a debacle. Why don’t you look into where all this money has gone? Electric vehicle (EV) sales growth in the U.S. continues to slow, according to sales data analyzed by Kelley Blue Book. In the first quarter of 2024, Americans bought 268,909 new electric vehicles, according to Kelley Blue Book counts. EV share of total new-vehicle sales in Q1 was 7.3%, a decrease from Q4 2023.
Tony says
It’s because of governors like DeSantis !!!!
Ben Hogarth says
Not sure where Florida Mike got his information from, but likely a Florida source or perhaps even Florida Man himself?
For those of you interested in facts, there are now well over 180,000 publicly available EV charging ports at stations across the country, which is double the amount we had 4 years ago when Biden first took office. The goal is to get to 500,000 EV ports available through the NEVI. So the plan is on track and doesn’t represent only “7” new stations across the country – which is an absurd misrepresentation.
As far as automotive sales, the entire market has been wrecked by gouged prices, spiked financing rates, AND by automotive dealers stealing government incentives for would-be EV purchasers by increasing MSRP. To pass the blame to the administration for trying to do a good thing, when once again, both banks and businesses are getting greedy is a woeful disservice to Americans who feel confused and frustrated. If anything, we should be begging government to take on the dealers and the banks to stop the practices and bring automotive prices down.
But what are we doing instead? Blaming the good actors and ignoring the bad actors. Welcome to Trump’s America. Where stupid reigns supreme.
Deborah Coffey says
Where is all this money? Being held back by our governor and others in red states. I DO think the thieves should return our tax dollars to the Treasury. Meantime, climate change deniers will end up killing us all.
DaleL says
Yes, quarter one of 2024 was not great for EVs. That was the only quarter in which sales went down. The sales in quarter two rebounded to the highest level ever.
2023
Q1 = 258,882
Q2 = 295,355
Q3 = 313,086
Q4 = 317,168
2024
Q1 = 268,909
Q2 = 330,463
Ray W. says
Hello DaleL.
A quick check of easily accessed sources reveals stories about GM’s Ultima battery plant experiencing manufacturing setbacks on a battery line that is expected to power much of GM’s EV lineup in the short term. GM sales fell significantly during the first quarter due to a lack of available battery packs.
Tesla, the largest American seller, shut down an assembly line in China, beginning in March. One source explained that Tesla is revamping its aging Model Y line of vehicles, one of its bigger sellers. Another source reports that Tesla is facing intense competition in the international marketplace. One issue is that Americans are buying luxury EVs, not utility EVs. Almost every other EV manufacturer that sells in the U.S. reports large sales increases in the first quarter.
As an aside, I am reminded of the scene in the Godfather of a character complaining that his new Ford came without bumpers. When the chrome bumpers came in, they would be installed. Until then, wooden bumpers would have to do. So I looked it up. With chromium in seriously short supply during WWII, many stripped bumpers off their cars and replaced them with wooden bumpers. Some cars sold during the war and shortly after were built with factory made wooden bumpers.
The EIA reported on May 14, 2024, that combined EV, PHEV and Hybrid sales were 18.8% of the overall U.S. market last year. So far this year? 18.0%.
The EIA predicts that overall market share of EV, PHEV and Hybrid sales will rise significantly throughout the remainder of 2024.
Joe D says
Nothing like Florida shooting itself in the proverbial financial foot by turning down Federal money for more community EV chargers.
And if the politicians are worried about the loss of gasoline taxes with the increased used of EV’s, the State of Maryland ( after accepting the Federal EV charger money), just assessed an EV gas tax fee of $200 every 2 years ($100 fee/year) for each registered EV vehicle, to make up for the loss of gas tax revenue, since EV’s don’t use gasoline, and EV’s still use the state roads, etc…..wonder why Florida couldn’t come up with such a COMPROMISE!?!
Oh that’s right the FEDERAL money was coming from legislation from those NASTY Biden Democrats ( that was SARCASM people)!
Shark says
Clueless ronnie is too busy fighting Disney and kissing t=rumps rump to do anything for Florida !!!
c says
Nowadays, you have to kiss the ear :)
Samuel says
Once again DeSantis proves to the State of Florida he is incompetent to be a Governor or any Public Official, who votes for these losers?
Joe D says
You asked “Who votes for these losers?”
…unfortunately…as Florida voters…WE DO!!!
And in the case of DeSantis, we (not me PERSONALLY) did it TWICE!
So we technically have no one to blame but OURSELVES. These politicians CANNOT be the BEST that Florida has to offer….can they!?!
Nephew Of Uncle Sam says
Every day I see EV’s driving around Palm Coast, yet as of yesterday over by Bealls new charging stations await to be activated. Installed months ago yet they are surrounded by yellow tape and off-limits to consumers. Might our city council get involved and get these working for those traveling that might get off the highway to charge and spend cash here? Not holding my breath.
raw says
Wake up. The electric vehicle’s concept is graveyard dead.
DaleL says
So the electric vehicle concept is dead?? I love my EV. It is the best car I have owned ever. I just got back from a trip to my hometown in Iowa. It was a 2,400 mile round trip. My car is 2023 Tesla Model Y. The Model Y was the worlds best selling car in 2023. It is also the most American car by place of manufacture and parts content. It is versatile, has lots of storage capacity, and even has a camping mode. After taking the federal tax credit into consideration, it was even less expensive than my wife’s Acura RDX.
https://www.kbb.com/car-news/tesla-model-y-was-worlds-best-selling-car-in-2023/
https://www.andreaference.com/blog/tesla-camp-mode-how-to-comfortably-sleep-in-your-tesla-model-y
https://www.cars.com/american-made-index/
The dude says
Why?
Just because MAGA morons hate them, doesn’t mean everybody does.
So why does it matter to MAGA if the car I drive is powered directly by fuel or indirectly by fuel via electricity created by fuel?
First MAGA wanted to invade my bedroom, then my healthcare, now my garage.
Skibum says
If the money is earmarked for a specific purpose, and not being used by the state as intended when the state accepted the money, why doesn’t the federal government take back those funds and redirect the money to another state that is willing to use it for the purpose it was given? It seems to me there should be stricter conditions attached to federal taxpayer dollars so idiots in state capitals like we have can’t just sit on federal money and not use it for the benefit of all of us who live in, work in, or visit Florida.
Joe D says
My guess would be, there is PROBABLY a TIME deadline by which the earmarked money has to be spent or the money has to be returned to the Federal government. That’s USUALLY how these funds work.
DaleL says
Just a reminder, EV DC fast chargers are almost exclusively used by travelers. Local owners of EV vehicles almost always charge at home. EV DC fast chargers benefit tourism.
R.S. says
Yup. And I’d like to be one of those travelers if that stupid governor of ours were to get with the trend. No way to blame Bidenomics for anything here.
Skibum says
Most locals travel at some point, and even going a couple hundred miles in an EV within the state, most people will be wanting to find somewhere to have their EV charged up before they get too close to the low battery warning. And what about all of the locals who decide it is best to evacuate to a safer area during a hurricane? It is difficult for me to swallow the tale that it is only tourists who benefit from having a network of fast chargers throughout the state. Whether someone owns an EV or a plug-in hybrid vehicle, it is extremely important for visitors and locals alike that the necessary infrastructure that supports EVs is built with the federal tax dollars that states have received.
Pogo says
@I push my EV (Okay, not a V, but I don’t need to drive anything, anywhere, to carry a gas can)
As stated
https://www.google.com/search?q=EGO+21”
Better in every way. Period.