No Bull, No Fluff, No Smudges
Your news source for
Flagler, Florida and Beyond

A Man, His 2 Sons and Their Dog Are Caught In Cop Chase of Felon, Fugitive and Stolen Car

| October 5, 2015

i-95 chase man and his sons

Frederick President, in handcuffs in front of his his two sons and their dog, at the end of a car chase Thursday on I-95, just north of State Road 100 in Palm Coast. (© FlaglerLive)

All Frederick President wanted was a safe ride to South Carolina with his two young sons and their little dog. He didn’t know that the people he hitched a ride with included a 16-time convicted felon, that a loaded gun was in the vehicle, as was a crack pipe, and that the vehicle—a van—had been stolen in Orlando. After a dangerous chase through Palm Coast that ended on I-95, President was briefly detained in the grass by the side of the road, in handcuffs, his two sons on either side of him, as cops chased after the driver and a passenger.

The cops caught them with a K-9’s help. The K-9 took a bite out of one of the suspect’s butt cheek. The suspect, Dana Mathes, 36, required hospitalization before her jailing on six charges, not including an out-of-county warrant from Lake County: fleeing and eluding police, willful, wanton and reckless driving, grand theft auto, cruelty toward children (for endangering President’s children), and other lesser charges. Jerrad Lamon Moore, 34, the felon with a long rap sheet, was booked on charges including cruelty toward a child, four weapons-related charges, and a resisting arrest charge. Both their bonds hover around $40,000.

President was eventually released.

The chase began around 4:30 p.m. Thursday south of Palm Coast on I-95 when a Florida Highway Patrol trooper spotted the Nissan Quest that President and his sons were passengers in, heading north. Its brake lights caused the trooper to run the plates, which showed the vehicle to have been stolen.

dana mathese arrest palm coast grand theft

Dana Mathes.

Mathes was driving. Moore was in the front passenger seat. Right about the time the FHP trooper behind the Nissan radioed another trooper to assist him, Mathes exited at State Road 100, going east toward Flagler Beach. It was obeying all traffic laws at that point. But a mile further east, when another FHP trooper arrived and both troopers turned on their police lights, Mathes made a U-turn near the Publix shopping center and started heading west, speeding at that point. It “recklessly maneuvered around other traffic,” according to Mathes’s arrest report, ran a red light at heavily-trafficked Old Kings Road and got back onto I-95.

At one point the van was going 100 mph, according to the arrest report, weaving and swerving and skirting the grass shoulder, which slowed it down. At mile marker 288, one of the troopers attempted a so-called PIT maneuver—an acronym for “precision immobilization technique,” itself a euphemism for a maneuver that tries to force another vehicle to abruptly turn, lose control and stop by edging against its rear than steering hard against it, sometimes causing the targeted vehicle to spin out. It appears that troopers may not have known of the presence of the two young children in the van at the time of the chase and the maneuver.

“The vehicle did not completely spin out but it did come to a stop on the grass shoulder,” the FHP report states—steaming profusely from its front.

Moore and Mathes immediately bailed and ran east into the woods. One of the troopers had K-9 Ronnie with him. Trooper and Ronnie gave chase while another trooper stayed with the van and, drawing his gun, ordered President out. President stepped out with his two children and their small dog. President was ordered to his knees and handcuffed as his children looked on, likely terrorized.

jerrad moore arrest palm coast

Jerrad Moore.

Soon Moore and Mathes were caught—with Mathes injured from the K-9 bite to her rear. The scene drew a swarm of additional FHP and Flagler County Sheriff’s units, and the attention of passing drivers, who slowed down traffic to a crawl and caused an extensive back-up.

Cops located a Taurus 45 caliber handgun on the front passenger floorboard, fully loaded, with 10 rounds in the magazine and one in the chamber. There was a crack pipe in the driver’s door handle. There was an open beer (Natural Light) and a full container of beer in a Race Trac gas station cup, to the right of the driver.

Mathes claimed she acquired the van from an unknown man—she specified he was black—in Orlando and that President had paid her $200 plus gas to take him to South Carolina. She put the blame for the gun on President, and said she ran because she was scared. She later said she ran because of her warrant out of Lake County (for resisting arrest and criminal mischief). Moore refused to talk, as is his right, though on the way to jail he, too, blamed the gun on President, and his running on the fact that he’s on probation.

President told cops he paid Mathes $40 for gas and $60 in cash to take him and his children to South Carolina after meeting them at a gas station in Orlando. He said he didn’t know about the gun until Moore threw it as he bailed out of the vehicle. President was taken to the Palm Coast Substation, where the Department of Children and Families was contacted, but he was not arrested.

Mathes and Moore remain at the Flagler County jail tonight.

Print Friendly, PDF & Email

14 Responses for “A Man, His 2 Sons and Their Dog Are Caught In Cop Chase of Felon, Fugitive and Stolen Car”

  1. blondee says:

    Nice job K-9!

  2. Anonymous says:

    Great job FHP felony squad!

  3. Common Sense says:

    So glad we have all those laws in place to keep people safe from crazy drivers. I bet if we had stronger gun laws there wouldn’t have been a gun in the car.

  4. Mike says:

    “Common Sense” says “I bet if we had stronger gun laws there wouldn’t have been a gun in the car.” Yeah, okey dokey – I’m sure these fine upstanding citizens would be obeying all of the laws. I can just hear Moore telling Mathes – “Hey Dana, we better not take the gun with us; there are laws against us having it! I certainly don’t want to do anything illegal!” You need to think about changing your name, pal.

  5. Scott says:

    ‘President had paid her $200 plus gas to take him to South Carolina. ”

    What is this this ‘UBER” car service?

  6. confidential says:

    Totally agree that we need more strict gun background and mental checks and waiting period to properly complete search thru all government agencies before anyone can buy a gun. Enough is enough!

  7. Dave says:

    “Totally agree that we need more strict gun background and mental checks and waiting period to properly complete search thru all government agencies before anyone can buy a gun. Enough is enough!””

    And everybody can buy knifes and chemicals to make bombs so what’s your point as its not going to stop people with hate from harming others,.

  8. Outsider says:

    Here’s a good rule: Don’t accept a ride, particularly with your children, from someone you don’t know. Does that make sense?

  9. confidential says:

    Knives and chemicals do not spray 10 bullets per second.
    Regarding bombs making materials that will have to be addressed as well but is not as easy and quick as a nuts being able to buy 14 guns some of them automatic triggered shot guns.
    No one wants to take your guns away Dave as long as you are a law abiding and responsible owner, then what is your point?

  10. Scott says:

    Yeah that the ticket, more laws to go on top of the old laws that are never enforced or punished.

  11. Valerie says:

    Mike, I think you failed to see that ‘Common Sense’ was being sarcastic. :)

  12. Jake says:

    Hey, we should probably make crack pipes illegal too . . . maybe then she wouldn’t have had one of those!

  13. Mike says:

    Valerie – you are right – sorry, Common Sense! The funny thing is…people express the same viewpoint and are serious! But, yeah, I missed it.

  14. Outsider says:

    “If you like your guns, you can keep them.”

Leave a Reply

Read FlaglerLive's Comment Policy | Subscribe to the Comment Feed rss flaglerlive comment feed rss

More stories on FlaglerLive

Get FlaglerLive Alerts by Email

Get news first. Enter your email address here:


support flaglerlive palm coast flagler county news pierre tristam
fcir florida center for investigative reporting
FlaglerLive is a non-profit 501(c)(3) organization | P.O. Box 254263, Palm Coast, FL 32135 | Contact the Editor by email | (386) 586-0257 | Sitemap | Log in