No Bull, No Fluff, No Smudges
Your news source for
Flagler, Florida and Beyond

What is the Roll-Back Rate in Property Taxes?

| September 7, 2012

No entry under roll-back. (Alan Cleaver)

The roll-back rate (colloquially referred to as the rolled-back rate) is a term that applies to the property tax rate as it changes year over year, in relation to property values. It is often heard at budget time and in what, in Florida, is called the Truth in millage process, or TRIM.
(Read a definition of mills and millage.)

Under the law in Florida and a few other states, if a local government adopts the roll-back rate, that government is not increasing taxes, even if the rate itself increases. That’s because the roll-back rate calculates taxable property values in relation to the total revenue they generate for a government. If the tax rate generates the same total revenue one year as it did in the previous year, then the rolled-back rate has been applied.

When property values rise, property taxes generate more revenue. For the total revenue generated to stay the same, the tax rate must decrease. If, however, as has been the case since the Great Recession, especially in states such as Florida and Nevada, property values decrease, the tax rate must increase to keep total revenue generated at the same level, year over year. Even though the tax rate will increase, it does not mean necessarily that taxes have increased, because the typical property that has seen its property value drop will end up paying the same amount, when the roll-back tax rate is applied.

Here’s an example. Assume that a house is valued at $150,000 and has a homestead exemption of $50,000. So its taxable value in 2011 was $100,000. Assuming that the house’s combined property tax rate was $20 per $1,000 in valuation, that property owner paid $2,000 in taxes in 2011.

In 2012, the value of the house dropped by $10,000–a 6.67 percent decrease. If the same tax rate of $20 per $1,000 was applied to that house in 2012, the property owner would get a tax bill of $1,800, which amounts to a $200 tax cut, even though the rate is the same. More than likely, in light of the property value drop, the local government will raise its tax rate to keep getting the same amount of revenue. Therefore it would adopt the roll-back rate. That rate would have to be $21.32 per $1,000 in taxable value.

The rate has increased, and strictly speaking that’s a tax increase. But under Florida law, if the rate increased by 6.7 percent but property values decreased by 6.7 percent, and property owners are paying neither more nor less than they paid the previous year, it’s not considered a tax increase, and government officials can claim that they haven;t raised taxes.

Of course, that law works to the benefit of governments and their definitions of taxes better than it does to the benefit of property owners. The reason: while government’s overall revenue can be calculated to stay even year over year, and with it the property taxes it levies, it doesn’t work as neatly for property owners, whose properties are assessed individually. Theoretically, half a city’s property owners could see their property value decrease, the other half could see their property value increase. To the government, it’s a wash, and a roll-back rate can look so innocent as to mean that everyone is paying the same year over year. Not so. But to the property owners whose values have increased, the roll-back rate would very much amount to a tax increase. And to those property owners who saw their values decrease, the rate would result in a tax decrease.

Curiously, the term–roll-back or rolled-back–has a very brief and limited history. “To roll back” means to reverse or to turn back, a term first documented in 1695. But the word usually implies elimination, erasure, curtailment or annulment. It does not imply evenness or neutrality, as its use under Florida law implies, which suggests that, in its Florida tax law usages, the word is being mis-used, with a hint of deception: if to roll-back means to reverse, reduce, curtail or annul, or cut back, a reduction in one’s tax bills would fairly be assumed. That’s not the case with neutrality. The word gives governments room to roll back a little clarity about a process that has always needed more of it, rather than less, even as, in Florida, the very process is called “truth in millage.”

Print Friendly, PDF & Email

2 Responses for “What is the Roll-Back Rate in Property Taxes?”

  1. Billybob says:

    My house is currently worth what it was worth in 1992. But my tax bill stays roughly the same year after year. Will my taxes ever reflect the massive drop in my property value? Each year I keep waiting for a significant decrease, but it hasn’t happened.

    Between the recapture rule and the roll-backs and the millage tweaking it seems like those in power are just going to maneuver the system to take whatever they want and it’s an illusion that it actually has anything to do with my property value. It seems like it would be a lot simpler for everyone to just pay a flat 1% of their house value every year, minus $500 if homestead, instead of monkeying around with the millage. Oh but wait, that means if our homes all decreased 50% in value that means our taxes would be 50% lower and the government would have to cut 50% of its spending. Oh no!!!

    I read a poll last night that 33% of Americans would be willing to pay increased income taxes to pay down the national debt. I don’t know who you 33% are, but I think you must be absolutely clinically insane. Fix the economy first (which really means fix HOUSING / BANKING) then when property values start going back up wages will increase, people will spend more, more taxes will be coming in, THEN fix the debt. Right now, with this stifled economy, this is the time to give people a break not to increase taxes. The national debt is NOT what caused the housing bubble, bank failures, automotive industry collapse, etc.

    If anyone would like to explain how reducing the national debt by increasing taxes is going to fix the economy, I’m more than willing to listen.

  2. Helen Gynell says:

    It’s not colloquial. It’s named that in language of the Statute: “That millage rate shall be known as the ‘rolled-back rate.’”

Leave a Reply

FlaglerLive's forum, as noted in our comment policy, is for debate and conversation that adds light and perspective to articles. Please be courteous, don't attack fellow-commenters or make personal attacks against individuals in stories, and try to stick to the subject. All comments are moderated.

Read FlaglerLive's Comment Policy | Subscribe to the Comment Feed rss flaglerlive comment feed rss

More stories on FlaglerLive

FlaglerLive Email Alerts

Enter your email address to get alerts.


suppert flaglerlive flagler live palm coast flagler county news pierre tristam florida
news service of florida
FlaglerLive is a non-profit 501(c)(3) organization | P.O. Box 254263, Palm Coast, FL 32135 | Contact the Editor by email | (386) 586-0257 | Sitemap | Log in