No Bull, No Fluff, No Smudges
Your news source for
Flagler, Florida and Beyond

Scott’s Magical ‘Tax Cut Calculator’ Obscures Nation’s 2nd Most Unfair Tax System

| March 26, 2015

Rick Scott's understanding of how taxes affect Floridians is a bit cloudy. (Rick Scott/Flickr)

Rick Scott’s understanding of how taxes affect Floridians is a bit cloudy. (Rick Scott/Flickr)

By Daniel Tilson

Wake the kids, time to celebrate “Cut My Taxes Week” with Rick Scott!

Um… “Hip-Hip…Hooray?” Or is that, “Hip-Hip…I broke my damned hip and your crummy little tax cut can’t help, I need health insurance!”

The main event features Gov. Scott and special guests (pinch yourself) that include University of Florida mascots Albert and Alberta Gator mingling with the general public at a special “Tax Cut Calculator” booth in the Florida State Capitol. There, you can see the miracle of fuzzy math at work. Just enter the amount you pay monthly for TV and phone services, say $100, and wait for the magic.

Holy Cow, look, you could save a total of $43 in taxes and fees on those services next year!

Before you go rushing out to book that special family vacation you’ve been unable to afford for years, you might as well take advantage of the rare opportunity to talk economic turkey with the governor. Chances are he’ll start by saying something like:

“Florida families know how to spend their hard earned money better than government can.

But you’re smarter and savvier than he assumes. Ask how that adds up, when so many low and middle-income folks with 10 grand in credit card debt spend so much dough on slot machines and lottery tickets. Ask why so many got trapped into mortgages from Hell, and lost their homes.

Oh, yeah…Don’t get discouraged when he doesn’t acknowledge or answer your actual question. It’s his thing. Any question threatening to disrupt his rendition of “Everything is Awesome” will be met with answers such as:

context florida“This year, Florida has a $1.8 billion surplus and we have the resources available to continue to cut $673 million in tax cuts, including our proposal to cut the cell phone and TV tax. Every Florida family will be able to get back real money back with our cell phone and TV tax cut.”

You could ask why that $43 compares so unfavorably with the $3-4 billion in corporate tax evasion he and his legislative allies let Florida’s biggest, most profitable businesses get away with each and every year. But why worry about tax fairness, when you “will be able to get back real money back” — to quote the governor word for word. Forty-three bucks!

The way Scott and Republican legislators insist on making a big ballyhoo about tossing us economic table scraps (remember how last year’s big “It’s Your Money Tax Cut” turned out to be a $25 annual reduction in auto fees?), you’d think they take most of us for ignorant and/or stupid. But you can prove otherwise this week, when you visit the governor at his propaganda booth

Ask how dare he try tricking a Florida middle class just treading water into thinking Republican economic and tax policies have done anything but create a record-breaking and ever-widening income gap between the rich and everybody else – thanks to placing unfair burdens on working families and retirees.

Ask about the recent release of yet another major study, this one from a nonpartisan economic think tank, ranking Florida as having the second most unfair tax system in America.

Just don’t expect real answers; at least not ones that make sense or are based on actual factual information. Try not to let frustration take over. But, if you are ordered to stop kicking the “Tax Cut Calculator” and told to vacate the capitol by Scott’s security guards, remind the governor of an old adage on your way out.

Facts don’t lie, people do.

Daniel Tilson has a Boca Raton-based communications firm called Full Cup Media, specializing in online video and written content for non-profits, political candidates and organizations, and small businesses.

Print Friendly, PDF & Email

7 Responses for “Scott’s Magical ‘Tax Cut Calculator’ Obscures Nation’s 2nd Most Unfair Tax System”

  1. BR549 says:

    What a bunch of bull.

  2. Nalla C. says:

    Rick Scott is a liar and a felon. And anyone who trusts our “voting system” is a fool. It no longer matters that our state’s “tax system” is more unfair than others. It’s time to wake up and understand that we are not going to vote our way out of this. Scott–and plenty of scum just like him–infect every state and local government in every state, county, city, borough, township and burg in this country. They only care about themselves, they do not care about the rest of us. And they mean to help corporations abolish borders. Whether they’ve been blackmailed into it, or they’re just plain old sociopathic losers matters little, too. We can only reverse course on this if we’re willing to look at this as their end-game. Otherwise, we’re all just fiddling while Rome burns.

    I used to laugh at people who floated stuff like that, because up until the last couple years or so, you could only find breathless wild-eyed speculation, rife with the most inane BS (sprinkled with an actual fact here and there) about One World Government. In hindsight now, those people (your Glenn Becks, your Alex Joneses, etc.) are probably formal disinformation agents retained by the treasonous faction of our government that means to dissolve it, to spread BS, lies, and memes like “Godwins Law” and “Conspiracy Theorist”.

    It’s all been a giant pack of lies. Rick Scott is but one cog in its wheel. If all politics is local, it’s time for pitchforks in Tallahassee, and we’d better get on the case with using them. It’s almost too late. .

  3. Karl Hungus says:

    I’ve been reading an interesting book (that really everyone should read) called “The Authoritarians”, which you can download for free from the author’s website here:

    I bring this up because it explains why some people keep voting for candidates like rick scott, why they continue to vote for them, and why they are willing to overlook almost any evil committed by them. It’s because they’re authoritarian followers, just like the people that voted hitler into office and overlooked his atrocities during the war, and just like the people that continued to back stalin in russia once his atrocities were revealed. It’s an excellent read, it’s free, it’s 100% backed by statistical evidence and peer-reviewed journals.

  4. Lancer says:

    Leftists usually have a completely interchangeable definition of “fairness”.

  5. Rick Gardner says:

    Oh I can’t wait to spend my $43. Maybe I can send it too Rick Scott’s next election campaign… NOT!!!

  6. OMG says:

    SO TRUE LANCER…. $43.00 in my pocket is better than $43.00 in the Governments pocket….

  7. Nalla C. says:

    So, Lancer, is it that “Rightists” have the only acceptable definition of fairness? Please, tell us how that addresses the actual subject of this article? Do you dispute the numbers being used? If so, please be more specific as to what it is you’re disputing and why. Thanks!

Leave a Reply

Read FlaglerLive's Comment Policy | Subscribe to the Comment Feed rss flaglerlive comment feed rss

More stories on FlaglerLive


support flaglerlive palm coast flagler county news pierre tristam
fcir florida center for investigative reporting

Recent Comments

FlaglerLive is a non-profit 501(c)(3) organization | P.O. Box 254263, Palm Coast, FL 32135 | Contact the Editor by email | (386) 586-0257 | Sitemap | Log in