No Bull, No Fluff, No Smudges
Your news source for
Flagler, Florida and Beyond

Combative Exchanges Punctuate Hearing on Broward Sheriff Scott Israel’s Fate

| June 19, 2019

scott israel

Scott Israel. (NSF)

In his quest to get his old job back, Scott Israel spent hours jousting with Gov. Ron DeSantis’ lawyer Wednesday in a series of combative exchanges highlighting two deadly mass shootings in Broward County that led to the former sheriff’s suspension.

Israel’s seven hours of testimony Wednesday concluded a two-day hearing before a Senate special master in an appeal filed by the veteran law enforcement official after DeSantis stripped him of the sheriff’s post shortly after the Republican governor took office in January.

In his suspension order, DeSantis alleged that “neglect of duty” and “incompetence” by Israel were connected to the February 2018 massacre at Marjory Stoneman Douglas High School in Parkland that left 17 students and faculty members dead.

DeSantis’ executive order also blamed Israel for mishandling the response to a mass shooting at Hollywood-Fort Lauderdale International Airport that resulted in five deaths.

“The state didn’t prove their case. There’s nothing incompetent or negligent about me. That’s not who I am. That’s not how I work. That’s not how I performed, and I hope the senators realize that and vote that way, but that’s their vote,” Israel, 63, told reporters after the hearing.

Israel appealed his suspension to the Senate, which has the authority to reinstate or remove elected officials. Senate Special Master Dudley Goodlette, who oversaw what was essentially a trial, will make recommendations to Senate President Bill Galvano, R-Bradenton. The Senate Rules Committee will consider Goodlette’s recommendations when lawmakers return to Tallahassee in the fall, and the full Senate will make a final decision on Israel’s fate.

Israel and his lawyers maintain that the suspension, something DeSantis pledged to do while running for office last year, was a political ploy aimed at winning favor with voters in Democrat-rich Broward County and supporters of the National Rifle Association.

After spending hours Tuesday answering questions from his lawyer, Benedict Kuehne, Israel on Wednesday dueled with DeSantis’ deputy general counsel, Nicholas Primrose, who repeatedly linked the fatal incidents to what he described as Israel’s failure to adequately train deputies, a position Israel staunchly disputed.

Primrose, who did not call any witnesses, concentrated more than half of his time grilling Israel on the airport shooting, before turning to last year’s horrific school massacre.

The governor’s lawyer criticized Israel’s policy of requiring active shooter training for school resource officers just once every three years, which Primrose implied was inadequate.

And Primrose blamed Israel for the failure of two deputies to follow up on interactions with alleged gunman Nikolas Cruz, including on one report that Cruz would be responsible for “the next Columbine.” The Marjory Stoneman Douglas shooting might never have happened if Israel’s office had acted on the reports, Primrose implied.

Israel said deputies failed to properly document the reports about Cruz, but that, even if they had followed procedure, there was nothing the sheriff’s office could have done to prevent Cruz from going on the Valentine’s Day rampage at the school he once attended.

Primrose persisted, repeatedly pushing Israel about why he did not require all threats of school shootings to be reported directly to him.

“If school safety was so important to you, why did you not have a policy in 2016 that if any of your deputies had credible information regarding shooting (at) a school, that it get automatically sent to the top, to you?” Primrose asked.

Israel said that his office received 700,000 calls each year.

“You’re not going to bring everything to a sheriff. It’s really a bizarre question,” he responded.

“Is it really that ridiculous of a policy, if it has to do with something you testified was so important to your agency… that you would want to know if there’s a threat of a school shooting?” Primrose countered, repeatedly referring to Cruz as “the shooter.”

“A shooter?” Israel shot back. “Where do you come up with the word ‘shooter?’ This was two years before. … You’re asking a question based on what you know in 2019.”

The back and forth was just one of many in which a combative Israel — at one point admonishing Primrose for “trying to put words into my mouth” — and an equally truculent Primrose crossed swords.

Israel repeatedly refused to answer Primrose, challenging the lawyer for making statements rather than asking questions.

For example, Israel at one point said: “I’m not trying to be argumentative, but you’re telling me what I don’t think instead of asking me a question and letting me answer it.”

Primrose also concentrated on Scot Peterson, the long-serving resource officer at the Parkland school who was seen on videotape hovering outside a building as Cruz unleashed a volley of bullets inside.

Peterson, who retired after Israel announced he intended to suspend the deputy, was arrested this month following a Florida Department of Law Enforcement’s investigation into the shooting.

Primrose played a videotape of a June 2018 “Today” morning show interview with Peterson, in which the officer claimed he had followed the sheriff’s office policy by remaining outside the building — an assertion Israel vehemently denied.

The resource officer’s failure to enter the building “had nothing to do with training,” insisted Israel, whose triplets had attended the school he referred to as “Stoneman Douglas,” where he had also coached football.

“It had nothing to do with policies. Deputy Peterson didn’t go in because he was afraid. You can see the fear in the video,” Israel, a former SWAT commander, said. “He was afraid to go in.”

But Primrose pointed out that Peterson had taken part in just two active-shooter training exercises over a six-year period.

Kuehne later said the FDLE charging document found probable cause that Peterson had lied about his training.

“Peterson had all the tools,” Israel said. “No matter what you did … he was just a coward who wasn’t going to act.”

Primrose also relied on findings of the Marjory Stoneman Douglas High School Public Safety Commission, a state-created panel that issued a 458-page report after a months-long investigation.

The panel, chaired by Pinellas County Sheriff Bob Gualtieri, took issue with Israel’s “active shooter” policy that said a deputy “may” enter the area where an active shooter is located, an issue that was included as one of Israel’s shortcomings in DeSantis’ executive order and which has become a flashpoint in the case.

Primrose pointed to a highlighted portion of the report that said Israel’s policy “is insufficient and fails to unequivocally convey the expectation that deputies are expected to immediately enter an active assailant scene when gunfire is active.”

But earlier in the day, Israel called the “shall” or “may” issue a “red herring.”

“The purpose of the policy is to give the officer discretion not to go on a suicide mission,” Israel said.

Primrose asked why Israel changed the policy to include the word “shall” following the mass shooting in Parkland.

Israel said the switch was based on the recommendation of Gualtieri, who is a lawyer.

“I felt that I was being asked to do it, in the spirit of full cooperation with the commission, that’s why I did it,” Israel said.

After reading a state law that says sheriffs are responsible for the “neglect and default” of their deputies, Primrose tried to get Israel to take the blame for Peterson’s behavior, saying that six lives could have been saved if the resource office had gone into the building.

But Israel didn’t bite.

“The only person, the only person responsible for the loss of lives is a horrific, evil killer that did things through sheer evil. The responsibility of taking human life, only the killer did that,” he said.

–Dara Kam, News Service of Florida

Print Friendly, PDF & Email

8 Responses for “Combative Exchanges Punctuate Hearing on Broward Sheriff Scott Israel’s Fate”

  1. jim says:

    time for Israel to “bite the bullit” and move on …you have lost ALL of the respect and dignity of the civilians, deputies, communities, and the “oath of Honor” you have sworn to uphold.

  2. gmath55 says:

    Scott Israel is 63. Why doesn’t he just retire and collect social security and pension.

  3. Agkistrodon says:

    “Bye Felicia”.

  4. Agkistrodon says:

    If he says it, I guess it is so. Problem is the Facts say different. Who am I supposed to believe, his spoken word, or FACTS. I’ll go with Facts.

  5. Concerned Citizen says:


    The actual person responsible for the shooting is Nicholas Cruz. He went in armed and killed people. He alone is actually responsible for the deaths of those students. We point fingers and lay blame all the time on other parties but at the end of the day the shooter is the one responsible.


    Sheriff Israel had severe issues with his department. Policies were not implemented. Nor were existing ones followed. That is why he was relieved of command. In the private sector when you fail to do your job you get fired. It should be the same in the government sector. Especially when someone is in the busniess of protecting/saving lives.


    Scott Peterson is a coward. What led to it? Who knows. Was it complacency? Lack of experience or training? I have served in the military and in Law Enforcement. I have been in combat and have been scared. Not going to lie. But your training kicks in and you know what to do. And at the end of the day you get your mission completed and hopefully make it home.

    His failure to enter that building and stop the shooter was inexcusable. I’m not a parent but damned if I would let someone harm kids. And he had a weapon?? No sir get in there and do what you have to do to make those kids safe. And if you can’t then you have no busniess being in the line of work you’re in.

    Scott Peterson will unfortunatley have to answer for letting children die that fateful day. But the real villian should be the shooter who should get no more publicity.

  6. weldon ryan says:

    What bullshist! Law enforcement officers are trained to wait for backup, not go on suicide missions! ” The first and best tactic is to find cover first unless in immediate jeopardy! A hero is nothin but a sandwich. A cops job is to go home to his/her family after his/her tour, not run into automatic gun fire! This is not 24! Even Jack Bauer sort cover! Politics!!!

  7. Trailer Bob says:

    @Weldon Ryan

    IF you have children, how would you feel if they were in the school getting killed while a fat lazy cop is standing outside the door…worried about getting shot? Even I would have gone in.

  8. weldon ryan says:

    @Trailer Bob
    I’ve been thru some rough stuff in my days. I meant what I said. A hero is nothing but a sandwich! As far as it stands Peterson is a political scapegoat for everyone else’s screw ups and for the politicians and grand standers. I look for indisputable facts which separates fact from fiction. Shame his good deeds will never be realized in his civil service or personal life. Where will your bravery be in the moment we will never know? But I know we’re all great Monday morning QB’s!

Leave a Reply

FlaglerLive's forum, as noted in our comment policy, is for debate and conversation that adds light and perspective to articles. Please be courteous, don't attack fellow-commenters or make personal attacks against individuals in stories, and try to stick to the subject. All comments are moderated.

Read FlaglerLive's Comment Policy | Subscribe to the Comment Feed rss flaglerlive comment feed rss

More stories on FlaglerLive

FlaglerLive Email Alerts

Enter your email address to get alerts.


suppert flaglerlive flagler live palm coast flagler county news pierre tristam florida
fcir florida center for investigative reporting
FlaglerLive is a non-profit 501(c)(3) organization | P.O. Box 254263, Palm Coast, FL 32135 | Contact the Editor by email | (386) 586-0257 | Sitemap | Log in