No Bull, No Fluff, No Smudges
Your news source for
Flagler, Florida and Beyond

Nine Charged With Animal Cruelty Toward Bears in 4 Counties, Including Flagler

| December 20, 2018

A bear in a Florida forest. (FWC)

A bear in a Florida forest. (FWC)

Nine people face animal-cruelty charges and other allegations after a year-long investigation into the use of dogs to attack Florida black bears, Attorney General Pam Bondi’s office and the Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission announced Wednesday.

Defendants posted videos on Facebook, Instagram and Snapchat of bears being chased and mauled by large packs of dogs, Bondi’s office said. The bears were lured with dog food, doughnuts, pastries and peanut butter in areas of Baker, Flagler, Marion and Union counties.

“In some of the videos, defendants can be seen forcing the bears to a waiting pack of approximately a dozen dogs that then repeatedly bit the bears,” a news release about the arrests said. “None of the individuals involved tried to call off the dogs or stop the attack on the bears.”

Robert Klepper, a spokesman for the Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission, said that while the fate of the bears is unknown, evidence suggests some were killed.

“The actions of these violators clearly show the intent to harm, harass or injure these animals, which is an unequivocal violation of Florida statutes,” Klepper said.

Eric Sutton, executive director of the commission, said in a prepared statement that “as conservationists and ethical hunters, it is appalling to think about the callous disregard for common decency and our state’s precious natural resources shown by these violations.”

Bondi said the “gruesome acts” were recorded “for the amusement of the defendants.”

Charges filed include animal cruelty, animal fighting or baiting, conspiracy to commit racketeering, littering, unlawful taking of black bears and the unlawful use of a two-way communication device.

Arrested were Lake Butler residents Dustin Reddish, 25, Haley Reddish, 25, Troy Travis Starling, 45, and William Tyler Wood, 29; Callahan residents Charles Luther Scarbrough III, 30, and Hannah Weiner Scarbrough, 27; Christopher Elliot Haun, 42 of Ormond Beach; William Landrum, 39 of Millboro, Va.; and Mark Lindsey, 26, of Moultrie, Ga, according to the news release.

Issues related to black bears have long been closely watched in Florida. In recent years, the issues have focused on whether bear hunting should be allowed and how best to keep bears from clashing with humans in residential areas.

The bear population in the state was down to 300 to 500 in the late 1970s, when the animals were placed on the state’s list of threatened species. Efforts to protect the animals have resulted in the population now topping 4,000. Bears were removed from the threatened species list in 2012.

A controversial hunt in 2015 resulted in 304 bears being killed in two days.

Since that time, the state has worked to reduce bear-human interactions through education and a program to reduce the costs of bear-proof trash containers in certain parts of the state.

In September, the Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission divided $500,000 among Seminole, Santa Rosa, Lake, Collier, Marion, Okaloosa, Volusia and Walton counties and the cities of Apopka and Mount Dora for the “BearWise” trash-container program.

–News Service of Florida

11 Responses for “Nine Charged With Animal Cruelty Toward Bears in 4 Counties, Including Flagler”

  1. Duncan says:

    Its sad that some bad characters can’t find hobbies that don’t involve harm living creatures. I personally hope they make an example of them.

  2. PeachesMcGee says:

    I believe in frontier justice – an eye for an eye.

    Convict them and let the bears have their way with them.

  3. Tom Davies says:

    And why would anybody do this, sounds real stupid to me, what was their reasoning for doing something like this?

  4. palmcoaster says:

    These tugs deserve the same death by dog mauling!

  5. gmath55 says:

    Just put all nine in a cage and invite the bears inside. Case solved.

    There IQ isn’t too high either. Posting it all over social media? LOL.

  6. Anonymous says:

    Scum bags. What kind of people would do this? I hope the Judges sentences for a long time and with stiff fines. Put them individually in a bear den and let the bears have at them, that would be their best sentence.

  7. Truth says:

    I know a good punishment. Abandon them in the middle of a wooded area unknown to them, naked, and slathered in bacon grease. Let the bears find them and have their way. Either way, karma will find them, and get them.

  8. Michael Brown says:

    Aren’t these the same kind of folks with four-wheelers to rip up the woods or pickup trucks with cages in the bay holding dogs they unleash on deer (and fawns; I have seen three fawns drowned as they fled hunters using GPS tracking)?

  9. mark101 says:

    Talk about pure worthless scum. If the courts don’t make an example out of them, then we have one sorry justice system. I say about $50k in fines each and 6 months in jail.

  10. Steve Ward says:

    Redneck low life POS

  11. KJ says:

    Throw the book at these criminals. Not only did they harm the wildlife, they surely endangered the dogs and taught them pack mentality which could threaten a child. Not to mention now the bears who escapedare now accustomed to human food and will likely become troublesome to neighborhoods. Many years of hard labor is not enough time behind bars for them, Usually the start of child abuse begins with animal abuse. These people are not likely able to be rehabilitated only kept away from society for a long time before they prey on children next.

Leave a Reply

FlaglerLive's forum, as noted in our comment policy, is for debate and conversation that adds light and perspective to articles. Please be courteous, don't attack fellow-commenters or make personal attacks against individuals in stories, and try to stick to the subject. All comments are moderated.

Read FlaglerLive's Comment Policy | Subscribe to the Comment Feed rss flaglerlive comment feed rss

More stories on FlaglerLive

FlaglerLive Email Alerts

Enter your email address to get alerts.


support flaglerlive palm coast flagler county news pierre tristam
fcir florida center for investigative reporting
FlaglerLive is a non-profit 501(c)(3) organization | P.O. Box 254263, Palm Coast, FL 32135 | Contact the Editor by email | (386) 586-0257 | Sitemap | Log in