Rep. Joseph Abruzzo was livid.
“Most of us have been part of this process for a long time, and I’ve never seen that happen,” he said toward the end of a contentious hearing on a controversial vacation-rental bill, as most such hearings have been for the past couple of years that variants of the same bill have been heard in Tallahassee. The bill proposed to all but eliminate local government regulation of the industry, handing a big victory to the vacation-rental lobby but upsetting attempts by local governments, among them Flagler County, to balance vacation-rental rights with neighborhood peace.
Abruzzo had taken the floor during debate over the bill in the House Government Accountability on Feb. 22. Numerous amendments were waiting to be introduced. A packed hearing room reflected the number of people who’d traveled from around the state to be heard, among them Flagler County officials. But Rep. Jayer Williamson, a Pace Republican, had just made a procedural move that would end all debate and immediately call for a vote.
By then, the vacation-rental bill’s companion in the Senate had easily cleared two committees and was heading for a third, its momentum reflected in the House. Vacation-rental advocates were buoyant, thinking this would be the year they would scrap a 2014 law crafted at Flagler County’s initial urging that restored some local government regulation. The industry’s favored approach was state “pre-emption,” meaning that only a state agency could regulate vacation rentals, and would do so with a very light hand. Local governments would be prohibited from regulating vacation rentals any differently than they would residential homes. Vacation rentals, in sum, would have the exact same rights and protections from regulation as residential homes.
The vote in the House committee was on a proposal by Rep. Mike La Rosa, the St. Cloud Republican who had tried the same approach last year but fell short in the final days of the Legislature.
“I’ve heard the question be called after public testimony,” said Abruzzo, a Boynton Beach Democrat who’s been either in the House or the Senate for the past 12 years, “but to cut off the public, to say that your voices have no right to be heard here in this committee where there could potentially be a close vote is absolutely wrong. And it should be noted. This is a point in the process that I’m quite frankly Mr. chairman and the committee, this is shocking, this is shocking that the public won’t be heard today.”
He spoke of the additional amendments still to be heard, of the controversy of the issue, of its central importance to Florida tourism, but the chairman went ahead with the vote anyway: La Rosa’s bill cleared the committee, 13-11.
It was a much narrower vote than the two Senate committee votes had been. Whether because of the mounting opposition to the bill, Abruzzo’s indignation or the way gun policy and school safety diverted the Legislature’s attention after the Parkland school massacre on Aug. 14, the vote in that House committee proved to be the vacation-rental bill’s last hurrah.
Just as it did last year, the proposal to scrap the 2014 law appears to have died. The legislative session ends Friday. But neither bill completed its runs through committees, and Sen. Greg Steube, sponsor of the Senate proposal, declared it “dead this year” in an interview with the Orlando Sentinel.
There is always the possibility of a floor maneuver, where an amendment could be tacked onto another bill on the House or Senate floor. But Al Hadeed, the Flagler County attorney who wrote the 2014 regulatory ordinance that numerous other counties and cities have adopted as a template for their regulations, said a floor maneuver would be unlikely in the next three days.
But he’s not celebrating. Hadeed, County Administrator Craig Coffey and various county commissioners shuttle back and forth to Tallahassee this session, as they had last year, to battle the bills. They expect they’ll have to do so again next year.
Steube is leaving the Senate to run for Congress, but he says the push to repeal the 2014 law will be renewed until the push is successful. Hadeed doesn’t doubt it. But he says the same factor that undermined the vacation-rental industry’s arguments will undermine it again in the future—namely, the premise that a vacation rental used as such for most of the year is the same thing as a residential home. It’s not, Hadeed says. “It’s being used as a kind of a hotel, a stripped-back version of a hotel,” he says.
That’s what’s been galvanizing opponents of deregulation, who say their property rights are being violated when their assumption–that the home they bought in a residential neighborhood would be surrounded by people who use their homes as permanent homes—is at risk of being proven wrong. But proponents of vacation rentals have made strong arguments about property owners’ rights to use their properties as they see fit. In Flagler County, the issue was focused over the Hammock, where the county is regulating about 100 or so vacation-rental properties. The county does not regulate owner-occupied vacation rentals, such as those that fall under the auspices of Airbnb: owner-occupied rentals are believed to be self-policed in ways that rentals owned by absentee owners are not.
It’s not a small business sector. Short-term rentals generate thousands of dollars in tourism-tax revenue for Flagler.
This year’s bills at one point would have eliminated a grandfather clause that would have preserved regulations pre-dating 2011, thus erasing Flagler Beach’s ability to regulate vacation rentals, and eliminate homeowner association’s ability to regulate vacation rentals as they saw fit. Both provisions were removed by amendments in attempts to win the bills greater favor. It worked, briefly.
The House bill eventually stalled, Hadeed said, because of “the greater appreciation of many of the members that this bill was going to undermine the single-family neighborhoods in a way they had not previously understood.”
The respite is bound to be only temporary.
Excellent! Home rule…rules!
When Flagler officials are involved all there is is under handed politics being played.
Knightwatch, agreed. Govern at the local level, what a concept!
It is time to protect our neighborhoods. The first step is to unelect politians that place cooperate investors ahead of their own constituents. Stop electing lawyers that represent the vacation rental industry and real estate professionals that profit from vacation rental properties.
Flagler County must send a clear message to Senator Hutson. You are out. This man has lied to his constituents and county commissioners. The truth is he alone tank Senator Thrashers bill that led to a water down 2014 bill given limited power back to local governments. He refuses to introduce a bill that would repeal the 2011 Senate Bill that removed home rule and took away the local governments right to use local property zoning that protected single family neighborhoods from incompatible uses.
These whole house vacation rentals with no owner present is a commercial public lodging business establishment. These dwellings are conducting the same operation as a hotel, motel and bed and breakfast. All these dwellings use licensing agreements. They are not Mom and pop operations just sharing a room. These dwellings should not be operating in our neighborhoods. Why are they treated differently?
Let’s elect politicians that will protect our neighborhoods. The time is now. Do not be fooled again.
Allow homeowners to do as we please with our property without County Interference,stay out of our affairs
I rent my whole house out when I want to go on holiday, the money I get from renting my home helps pay for the holiday. Stop painting this as a vacation rental business, when the majority of us are just hard working families who like to keep our options open
The moment you accept “money” for renting out your home. . . no matter what you need/use that money for. . . it should legally be regulated as a “commercial” enterprise. Maybe it could be defined as a “small” business. . . but small businesses are regulated also. Among the rules and regulations that apply include safety/insurance regulations that protect customers, in addition to zoning regulations that protect the peace and quiet of “residential” neighborhoods.
This whole issue is a slippery slope. What if people wanted to start renting out their personal vehicles or sporting equipment with no regulations? I certainly hope those deciding this issue are looking at the bigger picture, but I seriously doubt it.
Those legislators who do not recognize “vacation rentals” as a “regulated commercial” enterprise are simply in the pockets of the likes of Vacation Rental Pros, and we must VOTE THEM OUT! That certainly includes HUTSON!
Would you mind if I open a brothel next door to your home? Just wondering since a home owner should be able to use their home without county interference. How about a 24 hour diner? How about an auto body shop?
Yes Dave if you are operating a whole house short term rental you are required by the state to apply for a busniess license. You are also subject to paying an occupancy bed tax. You are also required to follow the additional life safety codes as stated in the Florida Fire Prevention code. This is the State not the county.
It is pretty clear that this operation is a commercial busniess. It is also designated by the State as a transient public lodging establishment. You operate with a licensing agreement just like a hotel, motel or bed and breakfast. So you should be required to abide by the same codes as every other public lodging establishment.
You just stated you are charging customers for the use of your dwelling. Sounds like a busniess to me.
Unfortunately Facts, everything you say is not the current law and what i do with my home is perfectly legal, your suggestions are jus exaggerated non sense
The county needs to tend to their own business before they tend to ours. They are trying to take over too much control because Craig Coffey treats the commissioners like they work him and not one single county commissioner has a spine and stands up to him! Everyone of the incumbents need to be replaced in 2018 elections—-the current elected officials are a disgrace to Flagler County.