A Tallahassee judge Wednesday gave the OK to Tampa entrepreneur Joe Redner to grow his own pot to treat cancer, prompting state health officials to immediately appeal a decision that could open the door to more legal skirmishes over Florida’s medical-marijuana regulations.
Leon County Circuit Judge Karen Gievers ruled that the 77-year-old Redner — who made his fortune as a strip-club owner — can grow his own marijuana because state rules prohibit Florida medical-marijuana operators from selling whole plants or flowers.
Redner’s doctor ordered a juicing treatment that uses live marijuana plants to prevent a relapse of stage 4 lung cancer, according to court documents. Emulsification, or juicing, of the “biomass of the marijuana plant” was determined to be “the most effective way” for Redner, a longtime vegan, “to get the benefit of medical marijuana,” according to Gievers’ order.
“The Constitution says what it says, and the judge recognized what I’ve been saying all along: The Department of Health and the Legislature can’t take away the rights that the Constitution gives you,” Redner said in a statement Wednesday.
Redner’s lawyer, Luke Lirot, argued that a voter-approved constitutional amendment broadly authorizing medical marijuana “unambiguously allows” the Tampa man to follow his doctor’s recommended method of taking the pot treatment.
Redner is forced to grow his own plants to make the liquid treatment because the Department of Health hasn’t allowed any marijuana operators to sell whole plants to patients, Lirot argued.
Siding with Redner, Gievers found the prohibition defies the 2016 constitutional amendment.
“Nothing in the amendment authorizes the Department of Health (or any other part of Florida’s government) to ignore the rights of qualifying patients to access the medical marijuana treatment to which they are entitled under the Florida Constitution, or to exclude any method by which qualifying patients may take their medicine,” Gievers wrote in Wednesday’s 22-page order.
The judge also scolded state officials, writing that the health department “has been, and continues to be, non-compliant” with Florida constitutional requirements.
“Until and unless the department stops violating its constitutional duty and adopts the mandated presumptive regulation, the evidence clearly demonstrates that Mr. Redner is entitled to follow the recommendations of his certified physician under Florida law, and to possess, grow, and use his own medical marijuana plants in a secure manner so he will have access to the medical marijuana to which he is entitled under the amendment,” Gievers wrote.
The Department of Health’s notice of appeal in the case “automatically operates as a stay of the final judgment pending appellate review,” lawyers for the state agency wrote.
Lirot said he will file a motion as soon as Thursday asking Gievers to lift the stay.
The state’s request to block Gievers’ decision — which the judge wrote applies only to Redner — comes as no surprise, according to Adam Eland, Redner’s partner in a business called Florigrown. Florigrown filed a separate marijuana-related lawsuit in Tallahassee last year.
“Instead of wasting the taxpayers’ money with an appeal that is a sure loser, the department would be better served to rethink their unconstitutional approach to regulating this program,” Eland said. “Judge Gievers made absolutely clear that the department has no authority to limit any route of administration. That’s what the amendment says, and we expect our state government to defend the Constitution, not try to judge shop their way out of it.”
Wednesday’s decision telegraphs what Gievers may do in a separate lawsuit initiated by John Morgan, the Orlando trial lawyer who largely bankrolled what was known as Amendment 2, the constitutional amendment approved by more than 72 percent of Florida voters in 2016.
In that case, Cathy Jordan and other patients are challenging a state law, passed during a special session last year, that carries out the amendment and, among other things, bans patients from smoking marijuana.
Jon Mills, a former University of Florida law-school dean who represents the patients and who authored the amendment, argued that the ban violates the Constitution, which he maintains allows qualified patients to use smokable marijuana as a treatment if their doctors order it. Gievers is scheduled to hold a hearing in the case next month.
Gievers’ ruling in the Redner lawsuit “makes the Mills case a fait accompli, or, as my friend says, a done deal,” Lirot told The News Service of Florida in a telephone interview Wednesday.
“They’ll get the benefit of that,” he said.
Meanwhile, medical marijuana operator Trulieve is asking state health officials to allow the Gadsden County-based company to sell whole flower to patients like Redner.
“Trulieve is committed to expanding patient access across Florida. In anticipation of this court decision, we sought state approval to provide this patient — and others like him — with the medical marijuana his doctor prescribed and stand ready to dispense it once authorized,” Trulieve CEO Kim Rivers said in a statement.
Trulieve got in trouble with state health officials last year, after the vendor started selling whole-flower cannabis. The health department sent the grower a cease-and-desist order after the News Service reported that the company had started selling a whole flower product for use in vaporizers but which could easily be smoked.
In a separate lawsuit filed last week, Trulieve asked a judge to strike down a state law that limits the number of dispensaries marijuana companies can operate, saying the restriction “arbitrarily impairs product availability and safety” and “unfairly penalizes” pot providers.
–Dara Kam, News Service of Florida
Fernando Melendez says
I feel that this can be a dangerous presidence and the worry about secondary consequences this type of decision might have, how do you regulate or keep track of who out of these patients decides to grow marijuana indoors in their own privacy for the purpose of selling it?
Good for this cancer patient. Let this man live the rest of his life in peace and less pain.
Mm patient says
Very good step in the correct direction.
Kudos to this judge!
All patients with a doctor’s rec. regardless their ailments should be able to grow their own medicine and not rely on the over produced over priced medicine grown by nurserys
These people we vote into office who then ban someone terminally ill a chance to lesson their pain threshold are no different than Putin and a few other autocratic and/or dictatorship nut jobs. It’s funny because this attitude is usually from Republicans for which a segment are evengelicals whom claim to be kind, loving, do unto others, yet deprive people, INCLUDING SOME CHILDREN, who have a very short time left in this earth and the focus then becomes about “Quality Of Life”, so these children can live out their last days void of pain. Isn’t this ironic from whom these hateful people represent. Religiously speaking, and taking this to an extreme, I would guess that the person committing the sin is not the child who wants to live their short life pain free, but those who prevent them. What would happen to these government officials if they took a healthy child and beat the crap out of them, causing chronic pain in their life? They would be in prison. Their actions are no different, they are causing pain and trauma regardless of the methods used. Society is so self centered these days they they refuse to look at things from other sides. My mother used to say a mind is like a parachute… It only works when it is open! Shame on these government officials. Vote them out or tell them to get to work and spend taxpayers money towards more important things like human trafficking, infrastructure, taxes etc. In my fifty one years I have seen elected officials become more mean, selfish, greedy (That’s a given), hateful, decisive and closed minded. It’s 2018, you would think they would be progressing, not backwards towards “Pre-Cold War”. It’s actually disgusting when it involves children.
We should all be growing hemp
Sounds like a great idea for those who rent vacational rentals and have 25 people in a home. A lot of time being wasted on this issue when it is a non issues. The cops wouldn’t have anything to do if they weren’t busting people for 20 or less.
John dolan esq. says
This mans constitutional Right to die with dignity outways the powers of the states “whim” of law. Also he had the money to fight the court decision.
Alp residents of Florida with a doctors rec should be able to grow their own medicine and not depend on overpriced mass produced garbage
Will Hazz says
“The state’s request to block Gievers’ decision — which the judge wrote applies only to Redner — comes as no surprise, according to Adam Eland, Redner’s partner in a business called Florigrown. Florigrown filed a separate marijuana-related lawsuit in Tallahassee last year.”
what we need in Florida is a movement to ‘Johnny Appleseed’ the entire state with quality hemp seed