By Ryan Storr and Holly Thorpe
In a preliminary women’s under 66kg boxing match at the Paris Olympics last week between Algerian Imane Khelif and Italian Angela Carini, a powerful punch to the face resulted in Carini withdrawing after 46 seconds.
Carini dissolved into tears, crying “this is unfair”, and “I have never been hit so hard in my life”.
Almost immediately, journalists and commentators jumped to Carini’s defence, raising questions about International Olympic Committee (IOC) policies and making many false assertions about Khelif’s gender identity.
The backstory
In the face of harmful inaccuracies and widespread online hate speech it is important to outline some of the basics.
Khelif has identified as female since birth and lived her entire life as a woman, including throughout her sporting career.
She is not transgender. She did not go through puberty as a male and then transition later.
Her passport marks her identity as female, thus meeting the IOC criteria for gender classification of boxers.
In her first international boxing competition in 2018, she lost five of six elite level bouts. She went to the Tokyo Olympics in 2021 as one of Algeria’s first Olympic boxers and while she won her opening bout, she lost her second.
Khelif has had some previous international success but she has been beaten by nine women boxers prior to the Paris games.
Boxing’s questionable approach to gender testing
In 2023, a boxing competition held in Russia and run by the International Boxing Association (IBA) questioned the gender identity of Khelif and Taiwan’s Lin Yu-Ting (who is also competing at the Paris Olympics).
The IBA president, Umar Kremlev of Russia, was quoted as saying the two athletes had XY chromosomes and thus were subsequently disqualified.
Elsewhere, it was stated the athletes presented with “elevated” levels of testosterone.
The facts are yet to be confirmed and it is not the role of an international sports organisation to be handing out personal and private information.
Upon request from the athletes, the IBA refused to provide evidence of the tests undertaken.
The IBA minutes (available on its website) state the decision to disqualify Khelif and Lin was initially taken solely by the IBA secretary general and CEO.
The IBA board only ratified it afterwards, with the minutes stating the organisation needs to “establish a clear procedure on gender testing”.
As the records suggest, the IBA did not follow ethical practice regarding the disqualification of Khelif and Yu-Ting. In fact, the very use of such tests to identify an athlete’s sex and/or gender are highly problematic.
Sex testing in question
Since 1968, some sportswomen competing in the Olympics have had to undergo humiliating tests “proving” their gender identities. This often involved visual examinations of their genitals in front of doctors and other medical experts.
Mandated by the IOC, “gender verification” tests were then implemented by international sports organisations.
Underpinning such practices was a set of problematic assumptions, particularly that a woman who is good at sport could perhaps be a man masquerading as female.
Beyond visual examinations, blood tests documenting hormone levels and/or chromosome testing were used. But as research has revealed, the effects of testosterone on performance are often overstated, and understandings of sporting performance and gender require much more nuanced approaches.
After many years of critique, the IOC halted such practices in 1999.
In place of outdated sex tests that fail to recognise the physiological and socio-psychological complexities of gender identity, the IOC introduced a new set of guidelines prioritising the basic human rights of privacy, inclusion and participation.
While the IOC sets out the framework in the hope of guiding other international organisations towards more inclusive understandings of gender, the guidelines remain contested.
Some organisations opted to take alternative approaches to testing and proving an athlete’s “true” gender identity – for example, World Athletics continue to use testosterone testing.
Boxing and the IOC: a clash of ethics
The boxing events at the Paris Olympics are not being organised by the IBA, but instead by a special IOC-appointed unit.
The IBA was suspended in 2019 by the IOC, and last year stripped of its status as the world governing body of amateur boxing due to concerns regarding its governance, financial transparency and integrity of its officials.
The IOC was also concerned the IBA refused to follow their approach in issuing sanctions on Russian athletes over the Ukraine war.
With the Russian leadership of the IBA, this position highlights another layer of geopolitical complexity in this case.
Responding to the media frenzy after the Khelif-Carini bout, the Paris 2024 boxing unit stated: “all athletes participating in the boxing tournament comply with the competition’s eligibility and entry regulations, as well as all applicable medical regulations set by the Paris 2024 Boxing Unit (PBU)”.
The IBA has responded by offering Carini and her coach a payment similar to the purse awarded to the Olympic champion (US$100,000).
Since the incident, Carini has apologised to Khelif for her reaction and the resulting abuse, stating she would “embrace her” the next time they meet.
The real issues for women in sport
In the contemporary context, many sportswomen who appear too powerful, too successful, or look “too masculine” according to a particular set of values are at risk of being targeted. Importantly, it is most often non-white athletes who face the most scrutiny of their gendered sporting bodies.
Beyond the ethics of the tests being used, the extreme levels of online abuse directed to sportswomen such as Khelif and Lin reveal new ways in which women’s bodies are being policed and regulated.
To avoid such accusations, many sportswomen are engaging in what scholars have termed “emphasised femininity” – wearing long lashes, jewellery, make-up, painted nails and overtly feminine clothing. This is not because it enhances their performance but to reassure audiences (and critics) of their femininity.
If they do not offer a convincing performance that meets limited versions of femininity, they may also face surveillance of their gendered bodies, and public attack and online abuse.
However, this recent controversy may be a distraction from the real issues affecting women’s sport, such as safeguarding against systematic abuse, which has been seen in recent high-profile cases involving Volleyball Australia and USA Gymnastics.
While the Paris Olympic and Paralympics may be celebrated as the first “gender equitable” games, with 50% female participation, the abuse faced by Khelif and Yu-Ting highlight the challenges many women still face in sport.
Holly Thorpe is Professor in Sociology of Sport and Gender, University of Waikato. Ryan Storr is Research fellow, Swinburne University of Technology.
The Conversation arose out of deep-seated concerns for the fading quality of our public discourse and recognition of the vital role that academic experts could play in the public arena. Information has always been essential to democracy. It’s a societal good, like clean water. But many now find it difficult to put their trust in the media and experts who have spent years researching a topic. Instead, they listen to those who have the loudest voices. Those uninformed views are amplified by social media networks that reward those who spark outrage instead of insight or thoughtful discussion. The Conversation seeks to be part of the solution to this problem, to raise up the voices of true experts and to make their knowledge available to everyone. The Conversation publishes nightly at 9 p.m. on FlaglerLive.
DaleL says
It is possible that Imane Khelif has either Swyer syndrome or a similar condition. She may indeed have an XY genotype, but with a defective SRY gene on the Y chromosome. There are other genes on the Y chromosome which can also cause this condition. When these genes are defective, the normal sex determination regions of the Y chromosome are not activated. When activated, the fetus develops as a male. When not activated, the fetus develops as a female because that is the default gender.
Thus it can be true that Imane Khelif is both a female and has an XY genotype. This “controversy” is most likely based on ignorance of biology in general and genetics in particular.
I am puzzled though as to why this is even a controversy in the USA. The Olympics are not being held here. The boxing contestants in question are not American. This seems to be a creation of right wing politics to stoke a sense of gender outrage against the “woke” left.
Ray W. says
Hello Dale L. Thank you.
I looked up Swyer Syndrome. Some babies born with XY chromosomes grow to adulthood with fully developed female organs and non-developed male organs. Though even more rare, some people are born with XXY chromosomes. I don’t claim any answers. All I know is that if we let politicians decide the issue, we might deserve the level of legislative and social dysfunction and confusion we get.
Laurel says
DaleL: It may be possible, but that is just a comment that ads to the controversy, and not proven. As I am certain you know, women who become athletes often lose their periods, and bulk up. That has nothing to do with being male, or having an issue with their chromosomes.
The reason it is controversy here in the U.S. is because Trump jumped on it, of course, stating he won’t allow men to compete as women in sports. The far right do not want to accept that women can do anything worthwhile other than produce offspring. When women prove them wrong, they MUST be male. While watching Jordan Chiles prepare for an event, I noticed she had false eyelashes. I thought “why in the world would she do that? Wouldn’t it get in the way of her vision, or at the very least, be distracting?” It would distract me! That’s how bigoted some people are, that it would cause women to over *feminize* their look to avoid questioning, even a petite, curvy, young lady.
I remember I worked at a club, Boca Lago (I don’t mind saying), in Boca Raton, where the men were paid more than women for the same job. My male counterpart bartender would show me his checks as a stab. He also would *accidentally* bump into me, or hit me while working, even though bartenders are really good at dodging each other while busy…but I digress. I know I was a better bartender than he was, and thought the pay difference unfair. I went to the manager and stated that I wanted the same pay, and a fair schedule. He asked me if I was a lesbian! I’m not, but WTF does that have to do with it? I couldn’t just be female and good at what I did. I had to be, somehow male, or somehow close to it in his sad, little mind. It was an awful place to work, in my opinion, but there you go.
These bigotries are examples of what I call “The willfully stupid.”
Sherry says
Thanks so much Dale L. Unfortunately, it appears that the rise of close minded extreme “right winged” politics and the fascism of fear and hate is spreading around the world.
Tim says
They may think they’re a woman, but will need a prostrate exam at 40.
Laurel says
Willfully stupid.
Sherry says
@tim. . . Huh? Most thorough exams are done in the “prostrate” position, which is lying down. That would be the case regardless of gender or age. Geez!
JimboXYZ says
boxing is a man-made competition, if one wants to compete in that, gender identity at the chromosome level, as humiliating as it may be, has to be done. When there are “Y” chromosomes that are generally acknowledged as what truly delineates male & female, thus men & women’s divisions, those born with non-existent or even underdeveloped body appendages external to he basis of DNA is rather irrelevant. Then when there are drugs that enhance performance that are borderline a sex change level of testosterone,m I wouldn’t blame the governing bodies of these sports to require extensive testing. Currently there aren’t enough freaks of nature to have a separate division for Men, Women & Genetic Freaks division at the DNA testing & determination level. Perhaps as this evolution develops further, there may be that. If the Algerian has a Y chromosome, would the Algerian box against more obvious DNA men ? And how fair would that be ? The meme of Mike Tyson identifying as Michelle Tyson is another grossly distorted concept of a man identifying as a woman that would be tantamount to domestic violence in a sanctioned sport such as boxing. Sometimes one has to be the bigger person for being that athlete to voluntarily refrain from competing. This is a contact sport, not swimming in a pool lane. And what is justified with the Algerian boxer is that there were women that outpointed & defeated the Algerian boxer. Still doesn’t diminish the fact that the Algerian hits considerably harder than her true female opponent. It just means the female boxer was skilled enough to avoid getting punched by a “Y” chromosome freak of nature. I don’t doubt that some dudes might get into the ring and get beaten by whatever it is they classify the Algerian boxer as.
This is full contact sports, it’s not modelling. Google Amelia Maltepe or any other Trans Models. Just sayin’.
Nancy N. says
It would have been shorter to just write “I don’t understand advanced genetics” Jimbo.
Jim says
Nancy N. – JimboXYZ constantly writes gibberish in these comments. He usually hasn’t useful to say and consistently exposes a true lack of knowledge on almost every subject he pontificates.
I whole-heartedly agree with your comment! Unfortunately, you’ll see JimboXYZ routinely spouting useless and pointless comments. We all just have to accept that JimboXYZ has little else to do in his life….
Laurel says
“… “Y” chromosome freak of nature”
Okay, you cannot fix the willfully…
Excuse me while I go get an aspirin.
Samuel L. Bronkowitz says
Ah, I see. Only white women with vaginas are women.
Tom says
Wait a minute man or women, who cares apparently by the picture she has been boxing since 1923… She is either in really great shape for her age or a time traveler. I think this should be investigate first….
On the real note… Think about how frustrating it is for her. She is female but obviously has traits of a male, probably worked hard to get where she is and now has to continue to prove herself. Remember there are two sides of the page in a story.
Sherry says
@jimbo. . . just when I thought you couldn’t get any more obnoxious and asinine, you’ve outdone yourself.
Flamingo Gary says
Just stop all of this division. Have one set of Olympics and professional sports for that matter where everyone can participate regardless of gender. End this controversy by letting anyone regardless of gender join the NFL, NBA, MBL or whatever sport they choose. Thats the best solution.
XMegatron says
That irish is a racist I support imane khalif she’s a great boxer period.