Without discussion or mention of the agreement, the Flagler Beach City Commission last Thursday signed an agreement with U.S. Immigration Customs Enforcement, or ICE, to deputize some of its police officers to enforce federal immigration laws.
Flagler Beach police officers trained to that end will have the authority to interrogate “any alien or person believed to be an alien as to his right to be or remain in the United States,” which opens the way to interrogations of citizens until they prove otherwise, “and to process for immigration violations those individuals who have been arrested for State or Federal criminal offenses,” according to the memorandum of understanding.
Local law enforcement agencies have always arrested individuals accused of crimes whether documented or not, but without inquiring about their immigration status. Now that they will inquire, undocumented migrants found to have committed crimes may be turned over to ICE detention after their local adjudication, or if they were previously adjudicated and were found to be in violation of a court order.
Neither Flagler Beach nor Flagler County have significant crime (the Sheriff’s Office frequently boasts of having one of the lowest crime rates in the state, for a county this size), let alone crime by undocumented migrants, without whom it is unlikely that the local building or hospitality industries–two mainstays of Flagler County’s economy–could function at current efficiency or quality.
The City Commission approved the agreement as part of its consent agenda, the portion of the agenda where several items are lumped together and approved in one vote, without discussion. The consent agenda is usually reserved for routine items, like the approval of minutes or recurring contracts. It is also used to pass through items in hopes of drawing little attention. At least some commissioners were not keen on making more of the memorandum than they had to, approving it with gritted teeth. Flagler Beach Police Chief Matt Doughney could not be reached before this article initially published.
Unusual and voluntary in previous years, the ICE agreement is part of a new normal. The Flagler County Sheriff’s Office, every other sheriff’s office in the state and local governments across the country are adopting the same agreement. They had little choice. The agreement is in line with a blustery Jan. 20 executive order by President Trump, inaccurately termed “Protecting the American people against invasion” (there is no such thing), that projects a stepped-up effort to deport migrants with criminal records, or migrants who have a court order to exit the country.
Gov. Ron DeSantis, following a special session weeks ago, signed a law requiring local communities to collaborate with ICE. Most states have a version of the same partnerships, but without mandates. Some, like Washington, Oregon, California and Illinois, have state laws prohibiting participation.
The origin of the 287(g) program, as it is known–following its section in federal law–dates back to an immigration reform law Bill Clinton signed in 1996. But partnerships between federal immigration authorities and local police were intended to be voluntary, and in most states still are.
Trump’s order pressured local agencies to sign up, and subsequent state laws, as in Florida, forced them to do so. The order claims that many undocumented migrants “present significant threats to national security and public safety, committing vile and heinous acts against innocent Americans.”
In fact, the proportion of American citizens committing crimes is nearly three times as high as that of undocumented migrants, and the proportion of Americans committing vile and heinous acts (or violent crimes) is more than twice as high, according to a recent Department of Justice study, and 20 percent higher than legal migrants. In other words it is significantly safer to have undocumented migrants as neighbors than citizens. The numbers suggest that by shifting police resources to undocumented migrants, communities will be more vulnerable to crimes committed by citizens.
When the Fort Myers City Council balked at signing the ICE agreement, the state attorney general threatened to remove the council members who voted against signing. They quickly reversed and joined a unanimous vote, some of them blaming their city attorney for having misled them.
If there was any hesitation on the Flagler Beach City Commission, it was faintly, briefly voiced before the meeting by one commissioner, who is concerned about the liability risks to the city. The federal government will pay local agencies for their officers’ training, but beyond that, responsibilities are on the local agencies’ budgets. Commissioner Rick Belhumeur described it as an additional “unfunded mandate.”
“Not only do we have to pay law enforcement to perform duties on behalf of ICE,” Belhumeur said in a text, “we also have to accept any liabilities that come from performing those duties.” He cited a part of the agreement that states that the law enforcement agency “will be responsible and bear the cost of participating law enforcement agency personnel regarding their property or personal expenses, incurred by reason of death, injury, or incidents giving rise to liability.”
Belhumeur was not thrilled about it, but voted with his colleagues to approve the agreement, especially after he read about the Ft. Myers council members. “I’m afraid to vote no or Trump will have me deported,” he said. Jokingly, of course.
Flagler Beach-ICE memorandum of understanding:
ice-flagler-beach
Deborah Coffey says
Disgusting living here in the age of so many Hitlers.
Marlee says
What the heck happened to Flagler Beach?????????
Shark says
I guess all of the restaurants will be closing !!!
Ike says
I wonder if they will be going to the sod farms and vegetable farms in mondex and beyond. I doubt it very much and what about the people who hire them? Will they be held accountable??? I don’t think so !!!!
Richard says
Reluctant or not I’m glad FBP signed onto the ICE program. To the best of my understanding the Flagler Beach Police Department is a law enforcement agency. That being said why would the city council or the police chief for one minute think that the federal government would pay for the duties surrounding questioning people and requiring them to prove their legal or illegal status. This is an area of law enforcement that has long been ignored, as it is a Federal Crime to illegally enter this country. BThe Police Chief, if he is unaware has to made to understand that part of law enforcement duties is to apprehend anyone who has committed a criminal act. So anyone in Flagler Beach or Flagler County who is not authorized to be in this country is a criminal, “PERIOD.” They need to be apprehended, questioned and turned over to ICE for deportation. It’s really not a difficult concept to comprehend
It does not represent extra work for the police or country sheriffs, this is something that they should have been doing right along. The mere fact that they have neglected to enforce the law with regard to immigration status is on them. Now that President Trump has taken a hard line with regard to illegal immigrants residing in this country, the police will be forced to uphold the law, which to my understanding is what we pay them to do.
Perhaps the FBPD and FCSO should get a cut in their annual funding appropriation until every last illegal in the city as well as the county are gone.
It’s their job, it has always been their job, and it will forever be their job!
I guess they prefer to target easy prey like Jeff Gray a natural born citizen and military veteran, who was arrested for armed trespass (while fully lawfully carrying a concealed fire arm in public) on a public sidewalk in front of “Funky Pelican”, in exercising his 1st amendment right of speech, quietly and peacefully as is his right to do! They chose to horas someone exercising his Constitutional right, while illegal (criminals) immigrant walk freely. They should have instead been out looking to find illegal immigrant’s residing in the city, which I’m sure they full well know where some live.
Your Mom says
Shame on you flagler county, but i dont expect much out of this county, just a matter of time
JimboXYZ says
Great opportunity for local law enforcement officer to perhaps grow a career into a Federal law enforcement agency position. Any employee is growing towards the next position in any related field of exertise. The job description with any law enforcement agency is to enforce laws. Cooperating with other agencies is an expectation. Cooperation happens among law enforcement agencies across city limits, county lines & state borders, why not with Federal agencies ?
Just a couple of examples.
https://www.actionnewsjax.com/news/local/officials-investigating-deadly-crash-in-yulee/469525036/
https://www.yahoo.com/news/fdacs-undocumented-immigrant-criminal-record-014200472.html
R.S. says
Well, it should be familiar territory to the town; after all, it was a Sundown Town! Target has changed; methods, the same.
Hmmm says
Most people commenting that this is terrible would be singing a different tune if the house next to you was filled with illegal immigrants from Latin America. Lets be for real. And if you’re not here ILLEGALLY, you have nothing tocworry about.
Joseph Barand says
When will Trumps Communist Escort be deported, when will Elon Musk be deported? Both both immigration laws. There are 100’s of thousands just like these who actually broke the law rather than simply ignoring it. Seems like rich and powerful get special treatment.
The dude says
They can start at Margaritaville.
As for Jimbo’s word salad on local LEO’s aspiring to advance… I’m not sure anybody aspires to climb to the federal level anymore… the trust that a career in civil service can lead to anything other than being terrorized daily by Elmo and incels named “big balls” has been shattered in ways that cannot be rebuilt. The public sees now that civil service jobs can only have a shelf life of 4 years max, 8 if the current sitting POTUS isn’t a moron.
Michael John says
Seems Flagler Beach Police lacked proper training when they arrested a person just for standing on a public sidewalk with a sign about Veterans expressing his freedom of speech in front of a restaurant. It’s beyond belief what’s happened to the USA. Question Authority!!! No shortage of folks wanting to make other folks fall in line.
☮️
Dennis C Rathsam says
THANK YOU MR PRESIDENT FOR KEEPING YOUR PROMISES!
Land of no turn signals says says
Well hell why not.Not happy here? You can always join Rosie O’donnell.
Truly screwed says
Bunch of racist Nazis sending people to concentration camps without due process. So America was bullshit to begin with and now it’s straight up fascist and evil. I don’t support this evil and will rejoice when it fails as Nazis will always loose in the long run. Let’s make Nazis scared again! Republican voter roles shows the Nazi supporters to round them up and never hear from them again… like the Bible says treat other the way you want to be treated. So shave their heads and deport them to another country.
Chris Conklin says
I think Richard should be deported. without these hard working people there will not be a single house under construction finished, restaurants will close and the local economy will die. I would bet his house is built higher than his neighbors causing them to flood but he could care less. Flagler Beach was such a great place to raise children and enjoy great family time until people decided there happy with there homes that were built by illegal immigrants but now that must be deported. shame on anyone who agrees with his nasty self serving ideas. There’s other places to live. Your home will sell quickly.
Angie says
Why are businesses hiring illegals to begin with? That in itself is against the law!
Laurel says
Aaahh, the MAGA Police comes to Flagler Beach. Get ’em some brown shirts.
Shame on you, Flagler Beach! I thought y’all were better than that. The taxes on residents in Flagler Beach have risen to absurd amounts, and now, residents will be paying for one party’s federal fear mongering agenda.
This is just getting dumber by the day.
Whathehck? says
This is for all the lemming’s comments: how will policemen know that you are a US born citizen when you are being questioned walking the beach in your bathing suit? “Illegals” come with white face and blue eyes too. No papers? Hello Guantanamo Bay. I will not send fruits to you while you are being processed (no body picked them).
Laurel says
Whatthehck? Maga is not worried about white faces with blue eyes. I’m of Norwegian and German decent. Chances are slim that I will be stopped. I’d almost enjoy daring them! However, some of the darker of my family members could possibly be stopped, even though some are U.S. natives. This is not about immigration, really, this is about putting darker people in their *place*.
How many times have Flagler County residents been threatened by immigrants? C’mon people, fess up! I lived in a “sanctuary city” for nearly 20 years, and was not bothered once. Not one single time. This is manufactured bullshit.
GOP are terrorists says
All my life I was proud of my country. That is no longer the case , it’s a total embarrassment to be part of this evil regime. They dismantled and destroyed everything that did make our country good. All in the name of profits for the very few and white power. Government sanctioned torchure facilities, no due process, gutting any support for the poor. Sad and disgusting. Hopefully the EU will form its own alliance and lead the world as the orange moron is a global embarrassment and completely incompetent diaper wearing racist.
RezyM says
Please release the names of the deputized officers who were granted this ability. Also, release the data weekly as to how many arrests were made, where and the location the arrested is being held. Be transparent!
FlaglerLive says
It’s a good idea, and we hope some organization will do just that. However, we’re not wasting our limited resources on a fabricated diversion.
Unbelievable says
The Flagler Beach City Commissioners signed with gritted teeth? Which Commissioners is quoted in the article? In light of Flagler Beach recent Felony arrest of Jeff Gray, which the state attorney promptly dismissed, the City Commissioners better think twice about this! The officers clearly lack sufficient training! Can’t wait to see how much that arrest costs the taxpayers of Flagler Beach!
R.S. says
I am as worried about the disruption the police may cause to innocent people’s lives as about a commissioner’s signing anything IN FEAR of a state or national government. The commissioners should act rightly in accordance with the law; but they should not fear extra-legal pressures from any agency to engage in any activity that is not in their normal range of authority. Too many Trumpublicans around here think they can frighten too many into submission.