No Bull, No Fluff, No Smudges
Your news source for
Flagler, Florida and Beyond

Striking at Balance of Powers, Florida Lawmaker Files Measures to Nullify Court Decisions

| December 28, 2016

Florida Rep. Julio Gonzalez

Florida Rep. Julio Gonzalez is not a fan of courts. (Facebook)

Florida Rep. Julio Gonzalez, the Venice Republican, on Tuesday filed a pair of bills that would be the first step in giving the Florida Legislature or the U.S. Congress power to override or nullify court decisions.

One bill, House Joint Resolution 121, is aimed at the state judiciary. It proposes a constitutional amendment referendum to be added to the next general-election ballot (or in a special election) that, if approved by voters, would give legislators the power to override judicial decisions by a two-thirds vote of each chamber for up to five years after a decision at any level–county, circuit, appeal or supreme court.

The other bill Gonzalez filed, House Memorial 125, urges Congress to propose a similar amendment, but to the U.S. Constitution, granting Congress the power to nullify federal court decisions. If the bill directed at the state judiciary wins legislative approval and clears the state Supreme Court’s review, at least 60 percent of Florida voters would have to approve for it to become law. An amendment to the federal Constitution would have to be ratified by at least 38 of the 50 states.

Gonzalez’s bills are a reflection of the Legislature’s latest assault on judicial power. Last year a legislative proposal would have imposed term limits on appellate and supreme court judges. The bill, proposing a constitutional amendment, passed the House, 76-38. But its companion measure, introduced by Sen. Travis Hutson, who represents Flagler County, died in the Senate Judiciary Committee.

Rep. Richard Corcoran, the new House Speaker with his eyes on the governorship, said he intends to make judicial reform a priority.

Gonzales, a physician by profession, is aiming his proposal at what he considers to be judicial overreach. “Indeed, we have seen these encroachments play out on countless occasions,” he wrote, explaining his decision to file the bills. “Supreme Court rulings have mandated that religious symbols be taken down from public places or be replaced with others. They have placed prohibitions on prayer in public schools, commencement ceremonies, and athletic events. Negations of laws prohibiting the desecration of the American flag have made the unconscionable legally acceptable, and judicial prohibitions on federal term limits have overturned the will of the people of a state, even if that will is enshrined in the affected state’s constitution. And recurrently, the distributions of votes in these opinions largely mirror the party affiliations of its members.”

He continued: “It is my concerted view that such provisions, if enacted by the people would curtail the tendency of activist judges to manipulate the law to suit their political views and agendas. Equally as importantly, this would force the people to engage the legislature in enacting rectifications to current laws that they see as objectionable or flawed, restoring the natural relationship between the people and their legislative bodies. This would also force the electorate to more carefully look at their candidates and their actions during times of reelection.”

Gonzalez’s more ideological approach, however, may be undermined current law and weighty precedents that give his proposals little chance of success even as they may become grist for further partisan attacks on the judiciary.

The Legislature, as with Congress, currently has the power to at least try to either diminish or render moot a judicial ruling, but only by passing new laws that themselves must then pass the test of judicial review. No state has enacted a law that would give a legislature the outright power to override a court’s decision. The constitutionality of such a law would likely and quickly be be in doubt, as it strikes at the heart of the balance of powers, which leaves judicial review–the authority to review and declare laws unconstitutional–exclusively in the hands of courts.

Gonzale’s proposal addresses only the state judiciary. But by potentially giving the Legislature the power to override judicial decisions, the proposal would in effect give lawmakers the power to invalidate decisions based at least in part on federal constitutional law, thus reviving the specter of nullification–an issue settled in 1810 with a U.S. Supreme Court case that declared federal law supreme, and that the Supreme Court has the power to strike down state laws that contravene the Constitution.

State attempts to nullify federal law have never been successful.

Print Friendly, PDF & Email

12 Responses for “Striking at Balance of Powers, Florida Lawmaker Files Measures to Nullify Court Decisions”

  1. I/M/O says:

    Another “Bloomin Idiot!”

    State Legislatures cannot overrule the Supreme Court. The whole idea of the Supreme Court declaring a law Unconstitutional is to force the legislature to pass a law that is Constitutional. Basic Civics 101.

    Vote this idiot out of office. He is as ignorant as they come.

  2. John Silento says:

    Mr. Gonzalez’s proposals to allow the legislature to overrule the courts is very scary for the people, but a dream for the rich and powerful. If we start with the premise that the very wealthy control this country’s legislation through their lobbying and generous campaign donations, we can see how this caste of rich nobility would push for the proposals so as to take away the last barrier that can guarantee fairness for all, rather than the privileged few. In simple terms, Federal judges are appointed for life and do not answer to the wealthy or corrupt. They may judge according to their conscience without fear of loss of a job. The only way for big money to stop them is to either get them out through term limits, or give the big money controlled legislature power to overrule the judges.

  3. Anonymous says:

    government trying to override laws…go figure!!

  4. Rich says:

    Another right wing wack job. Where do they find these people?

  5. Mike says:

    What is this man smoking. He needs to be removed from office. Lawmakers over ruling judges, sounds like the old west.

  6. The Ghost of America says:

    hey, who needs those pesky checks and balances, am I right?

  7. Ben Hogarth says:

    Rep. Gonzalez is known for being a bit of a lunatic and idiot savant. Unfortunately he also has a medical degree and is a practitioner.

    I don’t know what would be worse – my life or my livelihood in his hands.

    However, don’t mistake this legislation as the exclusive idea to Gonzalez.

    This is 100% a full Republican effort to takeover the State completely.


  8. Common Sense says:

    Be afraid, be very afraid. Idiots like him are coming out of the woodwork, encouraged by Trump’s election.

  9. RickG says:

    Do you ever notice that when judges rule against the right wing nut jobs they become activist judges… on the other hand if they like the rulings they become patriots… go figure..

  10. DaveT says:

    @common sense, idiots like him have been around for a long long time, way before Trumpie. And most are residing in Congress.

  11. Sherry says:

    We are a nation of laws. . . . that is unless those laws get in the way of a Republican agenda! Then those pesky ” checks and balances are quietly subverted one slice at a time. We must pay attention and be vigilant at every turn!

  12. W.Ryan says:

    We are a nation of laws that keep changing because these wacko’s claiming good intent hoodwink the uninformed or easily deceived at a time when they are most vulnerable! Lets take the mandatory drug sentencing laws in the Clinton era for example. Politics “Trump” Democracy!

Leave a Reply

FlaglerLive's forum, as noted in our comment policy, is for debate and conversation that adds light and perspective to articles. Please be courteous, don't attack fellow-commenters or make personal attacks against individuals in stories, and try to stick to the subject. All comments are moderated.

Read FlaglerLive's Comment Policy | Subscribe to the Comment Feed rss flaglerlive comment feed rss

More stories on FlaglerLive

FlaglerLive Email Alerts

Enter your email address to get alerts.


suppert flaglerlive flagler live palm coast flagler county news pierre tristam florida
news service of florida

Recent Comments

FlaglerLive is a non-profit 501(c)(3) organization | P.O. Box 254263, Palm Coast, FL 32135 | Contact the Editor by email | (386) 586-0257 | Sitemap | Log in