No Bull, No Fluff, No Smudges
Your news source for
Flagler, Florida and Beyond

Criticizing Israel Isn’t Anti-Semitic. Here’s What Is.

| March 6, 2019

U.S. Rep. Ilhan Omar has been weathering severe criticism over allegations of anti-Semitism. (Fibonacci Blue)

U.S. Rep. Ilhan Omar has been weathering severe criticism over allegations of anti-Semitism. (Fibonacci Blue)

By Sarah Gertler

Weeks ago, when the first accusations of anti-semitism were being leveled against Representative Ilhan Omar, I was deeply agitated.

Not long ago I saw her address these accusations at a local town hall. She reminded the world that, as a Black Muslim woman in America, she knows what hate looks like — and spends her life laboring against it. Her words were clear, bold, and unflinching.

When members of Congress not only continued to gang up and falsely smear Omar as anti-semitic, but even created a House Resolution painting her words as hateful, I wasn’t just agitated. I was absolutely disgusted.

Omar has criticized the U.S. government’s support for Israeli actions that break international law. And she’s spoken out against the role money in politics plays in shoring up that support.

Neither is anti-semitic.

What is anti-semitic is the cacophony of mainstream media and politicians saying that criticizing U.S. policy toward the state of Israel is the same as attacking Jewish people.

Like most American Jewish youth, I grew up knowing Israel. During holidays, I sang prayers about Eretz Yisrael, the land of Israel. In Hebrew school, I learned about the country’s culture, its cities, its past prime ministers. At my Jewish summer camp, we started every day with the Israeli national anthem, Hatikvah.

My image of Israel was a rosy one. When I finally visited it in college, I was spellbound by the lush landscapes and sparkling cities, certain I would one day move to this golden ancestral home myself.

All this emotional buildup made it all the more sickening when, in the years that followed, I learned the realities of the Israeli occupation.

other-wordsThe modern state of Israel was established by Zionists — a nationalist movement started by European Jews with the aim of creating a “Jewish state” as a refuge for persecuted Jews.

It’s true that Jews have faced centuries of brutal persecution in Europe. But the Zionists’ project shared unmistakably European colonialist roots.

In 1948, Israel’s war of independence led to the Nakba, an invasion driving 700,000 Palestinians from their homes. These Palestinians were never allowed to return, creating a massive refugee population that today numbers over 7 million.

While I was able to travel freely up and down Israel, the Palestinians who once lived there are legally barred from returning. While I wandered the marketplaces trying stews and shawarmas, Palestinians in Gaza can’t afford even the gas to cook their foodbecause of the Israeli blockade.

Zionism didn’t create an inclusive Jewish refuge either. In fact, the diverse Mizrahi — or Arab — Jewish population that was already thriving in Palestine was pushed out of Israeli society as Ashkenazi — or European — Jews became the elite class.

What it did create is an imperialist stronghold that continues to break international law by building settlements deeper and deeper into Palestinian territory, giving Jewish Israelis superior legal status to Arab Israelis and Palestinians, and attacking all who protest.

Since Israel’s origin, the U.S. has supplied tens of billions of dollars of military aid and ardent political support. Congress consistently ignores dozens of UN resolutions condemning Israeli abuses, and year after year gives it more resources to violently oppress impoverished Palestinians.

Pro-Israel lobbying groups’ considerable political influence has even pushed Congress to consider bills punishing Americans who support Palestinian rights. (Around half of all states already have such laws.)

More broadly, they rely on villainizing critics with false claims of antisemitism — especially when the criticism comes from a person of color, as we’ve seen with Angela DavisMarc Lamont Hill, and Michelle Alexander before Rep. Omar.

I, along with an increasing number of young American Jews, want to discuss U.S. support of Israel. Talking foreign policy is not anti-semitism.

What is anti-semitic — always — is saying that all Jews support violence and imperialism.

Sarah Gertler is the Newman Fellow at the Institute for Policy Studies.

11 Responses for “Criticizing Israel Isn’t Anti-Semitic. Here’s What Is.”

  1. Rick G says:

    When one criticizes the government of Israel they are no more antisemitic than someone who criticizes the US government is anti-American. Not only that I wonder how many people know that Palestinians are also Semites?

  2. fredrick says:

    Hmmmm…. then why did she apologize for her remarks?

  3. Agkistrodon says:

    Interesting, Many German’s thought the VERY same thing in 1938………………

  4. PCer says:

    This is a great article and something I have been saying for years. People need to do their homework, go to the library and do 2 hours of research and you will find everything here is true.

  5. Mark says:

    When one criticizes the American people/government for standing with the Jewish people against terrorism I guess that’s breaking international law. Nothing anti-Semitic here let’s move along.

  6. palmcoaster says:

    Excellent editorial Ms. Sarah Gertler. Thank you for the historical review.

  7. William Moya says:

    I don’t have any substantive disagreement with this writer, and i suspect we agree in a whole lot of issues. However tone matters, even in politics and particularly with sensitive issues. When you put own your wide lens glasses and look at history, when things go wrong, the default is kick the Jews.

    Israel is in a very precarious position, geographical and political, and they will soon have to decide whether it will be the “two state solution” or the “greater Israel” but whatever path they take it has to include the Palestinians, either as citizens or as neighbors needing economic, social, and political support.
    If this scenario sounds very similar to our own problem to our own problem with Latin America and Hispanics in general, is because they are.

    One more thing is you are interest in the middle east, since this is the place where everything stared I recommend that you read a first rate Israeli newspaper, Haaretz, and in the process you’ll get a view that will surprise you and enlighten you.

  8. mausborn says:

    Criticizing the Israeli government and their lobbyists is not antisemetic, enough of this nonsense. The disgrace is sitting in the Oval Office. The reaction to a woman doing her job, questioning a money stream to politicians, was a joke.

    But trump that praised neo n a z i s that was chanting Jews will not replace us and killed a woman fine people and many more traitorous acts still have his job.

  9. Bill says:

    But criticizing those who follow islam and use it as a reason for terror is anti Muslim?

  10. Charlie says:

    Pick one side or the other…….I’m with Israel ! And I’m Irish

  11. hawkeye says:

    agree with Charlie, I am pro Israel,and I am an American mutt and dont like ilhan omar, just as one poster calls trump a disgrace, I consider her as a disgrace

Leave a Reply

FlaglerLive's forum, as noted in our comment policy, is for debate and conversation that adds light and perspective to articles. Please be courteous, don't attack fellow-commenters or make personal attacks against individuals in stories, and try to stick to the subject. All comments are moderated.

Read FlaglerLive's Comment Policy | Subscribe to the Comment Feed rss flaglerlive comment feed rss

More stories on FlaglerLive

FlaglerLive Email Alerts

Enter your email address to get alerts.


suppert flaglerlive flagler live palm coast flagler county news pierre tristam florida
fcir florida center for investigative reporting
FlaglerLive is a non-profit 501(c)(3) organization | P.O. Box 254263, Palm Coast, FL 32135 | Contact the Editor by email | (386) 586-0257 | Sitemap | Log in