No Bull, No Fluff, No Smudges
Your news source for
Flagler, Florida and Beyond

Homelessness in Flagler Persists, But Minor Conflicts Cloud Accomplishments and Services

| June 24, 2013

The forum on homelessness Bunnell organized Friday drew about 50 people, including Bunnell and county commissioners and the sheriff, but no representatives from either Palm Coast or Flagler Beach. Click on the image for larger view. (© FlaglerLive)

The forum on homelessness Bunnell organized Friday drew about 50 people, including Bunnell and county commissioners and the sheriff, but no representatives from either Palm Coast or Flagler Beach. Click on the image for larger view. (© FlaglerLive)

It’s not that services or even money isn’t available to address homeless problems in Bunnell and Flagler County. But the money and services are fractured between agencies and by the many definitions of what a homeless person is.

About a third of the homeless are on the streets or living in tents in out-of-the-way places by choice. Another third are homeless because of drugs or alcohol problems. And another third are homeless because of life-changing shocks: sudden unemployment, bankruptcy, illness. What money is available from government and non-profit agencies is parceled out among those needs, and regulated by them: money earmarked for families with children can’t be spent on the adult homeless man indulging a drug addiction. Money earmarked for addicts can’t be spent on subsidizing shelters like Bunnell’s Sheltering Tree at First United Methodist Church.

And there is no single, central clearinghouse for homeless money or programs, no central place that administers all sources of funding and parcels out all possible sources of help, reducing duplication or making it easier for the homeless themselves to know where to turn.

Those are some of the issues an audience of about 50 people learned, or heard again, during a two-hour forum on Flagler County’s homeless problem. The forum, held Friday afternoon at the old Bunnell City Hall, was organized  by Bunnell City Manager Armando Martinez and Mayor Catherine Robinson as the latest response to the latest complaints focusing, as they have in the past, on homeless people gathering at First United Methodist Church.

“It sounds like the programs are in place,” County Commission Chairman Nate McLaughlin said at the end of the forum. “I think the key here is to coordinate it. Maybe there needs to be a liaison between the existing programs so we can get people to them. There’s always going to be cracks, and when you find a crack, try to fill it. I’m very encouraged by the dialogue today.”

The complaints have always been vague and anecdotal, as sensational as they have been unsubstantiated: that the homeless who get taken care of by the church are a source of trouble in Bunnell, that they loiter, litter, light fires, scare residents at all hours of the night and have caused crime to increase. The latter charge has yet to be substantiated by the Bunnell Police Department itself (the department never made the charge: it’s been made, without documentation, by residents), whose chief, Jeff Hoffman, has told the city commission that the city will not arrest its way out of the homeless problem.

The one institution that has done the most by far to help the homeless—and in Bunnell, the only institution that has done anything at all to do so—is the church, with the Sheltering Tree organization that it shelters. For that, the church has been the lightning rod of criticism, but also, in a more positive sense, the trigger of an ongoing discussion about homelessness that would not have taken place without the church’s perseverance: it has refused to back down. Homelessness has been just as resolute.

The meeting generated a lot of varied ideas with a panel that included representatives from the Volusia-Flagler Coalition for the Homeless, Flagler County Workforce Development, the Sheltering Tree, the United Way of Volusia and Flagler County, which channels a lot of money into homeless programs, and a member of the Jacksonville Homeless Coalition. Beth Gardner, the pastor at First United Methodist Church, was also at the table. They all spoke of their roles and the services or money they contribute.


Absent from the table were two significant players: a representative from Flagler County government (although three county commissioners and County Administrator Craig Coffey were in the audience for much of the forum), and one from Flagler County schools. Both agencies contribute big resources toward homeless mitigation. Those services don’t often get recognized, because they’re part of larger bureaucracies. But they are particularly effective at homeless prevention: the county coordinates a monthly outreach program, Access Flagler, that provides food, clothing, grooming and legal services and other help to the homeless when it’s held at the County Fairgrounds the first Friday of every month. It underwrites an indigent health care program, provides rent and utility assistance to prevent homelessness, and manages grants that offer related services. The county is also the organizer of the annual Feed Flagler initiative at Thanksgiving, which provides free food to some 2,000 people the day before Thanksgiving, and a week’s worth of groceries to hundreds of families. The school district has its own administrative efforts to track and help more than 200 children classified as homeless, even though they may not be in the streets: the moment a family with children is in transitional housing, that family is categorized as homeless.

Representatives from either Palm Coast or Flagler Beach were also absent, either at the table or in the audience.

But the more the web of homelessness—whether its extent or the variety of services available to address it—was woven before Friday’s audience, the more Bunnell’s particular problem appeared to sharpen as only one particularly visible part of the issue, with little left to address it other than what such organizations as the Sheltering Tree and the church were, in fact, providing. Some people who spoke to the panel suggested that Bunnell or the county could—through a non-profit, through donated land or a house constructed by Habitat for Humanity—create some form of transitional housing system where the homeless who gather at the church could instead be housed, such a plan would entail more money and manpower than is available currently.

And the panelists themselves on several occasions commended Bunnell and Flagler for doing what’s already being done to address the matter. In other words, the notion that Flagler is not addressing its problem is more fallacy than truth, though the manner in which one aspect of the problem has been highlighted—the homeless who gather at the Methodist Church—may have disproportionately skewed the issue, distorting its extent and gravity.

Charles Gardner, who is married to Beth Gardner, the pastor at First United Methodist Church, addressed the assembly toward the end of the forum to say that the meeting was called after just two people complained about two homeless people. The two homeless individuals in question have left town, Gardner said.

“We have to be careful with the words that are used, how we say them,” Gardner said. “The city commissioner has stated: ‘this has been an ongoing issue,’ and although she believes Rev. Garden is doing what she believes in, ‘the issue is real and it is creating blight. These people are begging money, hanging out in front of the convenience store, and these same persons are hanging out at the church. It is a huge problem for our small city.’ I would like to see what blight is created. I would like to see how huge the problem is.”

Martinez, the Bunnell city manager, attended the forum from the back of the room, with his community development director, Mick Cuthbertson, moderating it. “This is a first step in the right direction, but it’s not the end,” Martinez said. “The only way we’re going to solve this problem is working together. I don’t think it’s Bunnell as the responsible party, I think it’s Bunnell taking a lead role in an issue that affects the entire county. We’ll do the best we can in what we have.”

Print Friendly

8 Responses for “Homelessness in Flagler Persists, But Minor Conflicts Cloud Accomplishments and Services”

  1. Charles Gardner says:

    Noticeably absent from the forum were Bunnell City Commissioners Tucker, Rogers and Baxley.

  2. r&r says:

    Why not open up and allow them to stay in that Taj Mahal county building. At least it will be put to some good use.. Maybe the school board will help set this up.. Ya Right!!!!

    • Carol Tibbs says:

      Better yet buy and convert the old hospital into a homeless shelter.

      • justaperson says:

        Using the old hospital as a homeless shelter was pitched to the Bunnell Commission several years ago. There was a ministry that had the financial backing and only needed approval by the City to do so. The City of Bunnell Commissioners snubbed their noses at the idea because they didn’t want it in their back yard. Glad to see it worked out for them

  3. Robert says:

    Palm Coast is probably looking for a way to write an ordinance that would make homelessness a city code violation.

  4. Popo3984 says:

    Why would those three be there they don’t care about the city unless its some kind of hidden agenda for them

  5. Ann says:

    First and foremost the complaints are very real. Proof verified visually as well as on camera photos and everyone that’s not in denial knows this The Methodist church enables the problems by giving street people tents so they can go live and deal drugs in the woods as well as feeding them. Yes they do live all around our homes and everyone knows this in downtown Bunnell.. I believe in helping people in need I have given to others when I had little food for myself. However, When the church is advertising as a mission and the a lot of the same people return yearly to hang out for the winter. some as far as VA, New Hampshire, other cold states in the winter and people are driving around with out of state much less not even local Florida tags looking for the mission this is not helping Flagler County at all. We have enough of our own homeless all over Flagler county. This is serious county problem as many live in vacant lots all around you and in our county parks, beaches where children play etc. And even with all donations the church gets money per head from salvation army, as well as other places. Also many other churches help all over the county not just in Bunnell,. This church seems to care only about the money hardly any of the original church members still attend here it has become such a disgrace and there are also some very alarming stories of killings, to the people who go there for help. Assault ,and battery on church grounds disrupting the neighborhood, as well as a few success stories. We need and countywide program , mental health and background checks for all those helped at perhaps by police for the people at this this facility as sex offender and people with warrants are hiding here and leaving the people in downtown living in fear. Find a facility get all churches to work together and provide the above mentioned services to track how much they are being helped instead of con Some people are living better than most of us. If We are true Christians as professed this can be accomplished by our county together and not just one facility trying to get all the glory when they are destroying others. It can be accomplished however must be done properly to protect everyone

Leave a Reply

Read FlaglerLive's Comment Policy | Subscribe to the Comment Feed rss flaglerlive comment feed rss

More stories on FlaglerLive
Loading

ADVERTISEMENTS

support flaglerlive palm coast flagler county news pierre tristam
news service of florida

Subscribe to FlaglerLive

Get immediate notification of new stories.

Advertisement
Log in
| FlaglerLive, P.O. Box 354263, Palm Coast, FL 32135-4263 | 386/586-0257

FlaglerLive.com