No Bull, No Fluff, No Smudges
Your news source for
Flagler, Florida and Beyond

Trial May Settle Ginn-County Dispute Over Towering Condo at Hammock Dunes

| December 15, 2010

Signature development over a signature golf course.

The Hammock Dunes “development of regional impact” is 22 years old. It’s virtually built out. Admiral Corp. a subsidiary of ITT, built thousands of units before the development was taken over by Bobby Ginn, before his operation was taken over by Lubert-Adler. In some sections of the development, building densities ended up being lower than those approved by county government. That means the developer had some 561 units it was allowed to build in certain clusters of the development, but never did.

To the horror of neighboring residents, the developer now wants to do so in a manner and a spot never approved in the original development order: it would be a towering 541-apartment oceanfront condominium hotel on a golf course, and it would re-route 16th Road to create more land for the development. That road’s right of way would no longer belong to the county. The golf course would remain, but would be reconfigured around the new building. The proposal amounts to high-scale redevelopment. The county and local property owners and associations—including the Ocean Hammock Property Owners Association and the Hammock Beach Club Condominium—objected. The developer, naturally, objected to the objection, claiming it was doing nothing it wasn’t entitled to do by agreement.

Almost two years of haggling has led to this: a three-day trial began this morning in front of Donald Alexander, an administrative law judge in Bunnell, to settle the dispute between the county and property owners on one side and Lubert-Adler, Ginn and the Admiral Corporation (the original developer of Hammock Dunes) on the other. Alexander won’t rule so much as make a determination that he’ll forward to the Florida Cabinet, which will make the final ruling. (Don Toby has clear analyses of the case here and here.)

Ginn-Lubert-Adler’s contention is that its development plan is consistent with its original “development of regional impact” order and the county’s development regulations. All it’s doing, the developer claims, is creating a new building cluster and shifting building densities it never used. The county enacted new land development regulations subsequent to Hammock Dunes’ development, but those regulations were not part of the original development order. The county calls Ginn’s latest approach “unprecedented in the 26 year history” of the development. “If approved,” the county contends, “the proposed development will cause adverse impacts to neighboring properties and to the public’s use and enjoyment of the public beach adjacent to the area proposed for development.”

In its wrangles with the county and the property owners, Lubert-Adler amended its proposal in an effort to reach a settlement before the trial, reducing the mass of the building to 289 units and lowering its height slightly to 77 feet. (That doesn’t mean the developer would not build the remaining 272 units: rather, it would build them outside the original development zone.) The developer also pledged to “work with the Nicklaus organization to ensure that the construction of new or replacement golf course facilities at a suitable location within the platted golf course property will not adversely affect the ‘Signature Course’ designation currently enjoyed by the golf course (sic.).”

The proposal didn’t mollify opponents.

“After review of Ginn’s proposal, my clients were somewhat dumbfounded,” Michael Chiumento III, the attorney representing property owners associations, wrote at the end of November. The proposal was “a retreat” from where previous settlement negotiations had gone. “The proposal increases building height and provides a floor area ratio that would allow residential building stories of approximately 130,000 square feet (about twice the size of anything yet proposed),” Chiumento wrote. Other concerns: the total building height would be 97 feet, setbacks would be diminished, and even with a limit of 289 units, the density would exceed 24 units per acre, “more dense than any other cluster currently permitted or developed within the entire” development.

“As you can see,” Chiumento concluded, “Ginn’s proposal leaves a lot to be desired.”

The Flagler County Commission heard the settlement proposal in a Dec. 2 meeting. After hearing testimony that included the voices of several outraged neighboring residents of the proposed development, the county roundly rejected the proposed settlement, leading to this week’s trial.

Print Friendly

6 Responses for “Trial May Settle Ginn-County Dispute Over Towering Condo at Hammock Dunes”

  1. PC MAN says:

    I’ve got the feeling big businesses emboldened by an all republican government will now start throwing their weight around. As Gov. Fraud Scott said “Florida is now for sale” or “open for business” something like that.

  2. Kari says:

    Hammock Dunes is not the same community as Hammock Beach. This article is not accurate. Hammock Dunes was developed by ITT and then HD Associates. Ginn’s involvement and development in the Hammock Beach area is what the true topic of this article is.

  3. Depressed Tomato says:

    What did Bobby Ginn have to do with Hammock Dunes? Thought he was all Hammock Beach/Ocean Hammock? And is the proposed timeshares / “towering condo in Hammock Dunes,” as you have in the headline of the article, to be built as part of Hammock Dunes or the Hammock Beach/Ocean Hammock resorts?
    Hammock Confused

  4. PalmCoastPioneers says:

    We really miss all that acreage, our Palm Coast Beach Club, ( SunSport ) , and our Palm Coast Motel/PalmCoast Sheraton Resort, pledge Amenites with features by Levitt I.T.T. to us, and further listed as ‘Exhibits’ in the Federally ordered Compliance Report pursuant F.T.Commissions REDRESS order C-2854.

  5. PalmCoastPioneers says:

    Some of the few items of Federal REDRESS that we miss alot:
    Palm Coast, Florida – If you’re not among the lucky 11,000 or so who live here all the time, you can still enjoy the Palm Coast life for a week or two or more, at vacation resorts among Florida’s finest.
    Seeing is believing, so we shall let pictures do most of the talking.
    A pelican’s view of a people’s paradise…the Palm Coast beach, and new beach club, a place in the sun for vacationers and residents.
    The Sheraton Palm Coast Resort and Palm Coast Marina…early evening.
    The Harbor Club vacation ownership resort…Villas surrounding Oak Tree Island.
    You’ve seen the photographs. Now see the real thing. For Harbor Club sales information—vacations for a lifetime–contact your nearest Palm Coast sales office or call toll-free 1.900.874.1828 and ask for the Harbor Club at extension 870.
    To reserve your waterfront room at the Sheraton, call 904. 445.3000 and ask for the Harbor Club at extension 870.
    Palm Coast property owners can arrange for a holiday through area sales offices

    The PalmCoaster , Winter 1988, pp. 10-11.

  6. Willy says:

    The area is built up enough. The hammock beach development and Mr. Ginn are slowly taking our county’s public beach away.

    They have already closed beach driving down by hiding behind the sea turtle patrol, and citing the enviroment. Dont get me wrong the enviroment is very important and shoud be protected. But you never heard the negative effects of condo lighting on sea turtle hatchlings.. It was hype about how many sea turtles are killed by cars.. Now they want to close some of the most beautiful beach parks in the county for yet another retirement-vacation condo.

    Enough is enough Mr. Ginn Leave Flagler alone, hide in chapter 11 protection, and find another beach.

Leave a Reply

Read FlaglerLive's Comment Policy | Subscribe to the Comment Feed rss flaglerlive comment feed rss

More stories on FlaglerLive


suppert flaglerlive flagler live palm coast flagler county news pierre tristam florida
fcir florida center for investigative reporting

Subscribe to FlaglerLive

Get immediate notification of new stories.

Log in
| FlaglerLive, P.O. Box 354263, Palm Coast, FL 32135-4263 | 386/586-0257